Title: A method of “Noninjecting Resection using Bipolar Soft coagulation mode; NIRBS” for
superficial non-ampullary duodenal epithelial tumor: A pilot study
Version: 6 Date: 31 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
As highlighted in my original comments, I disagree with the comment in the introduction
that present techniques (except for ESD) are high risk for removal of duodenal adenomas.
Sessile polyp preinjection and resection with cold snare or electrocautery snare really very safe,
particularly in the small mucosal defects that can be closed with clips.
This normal technique described in this pilot study can only really be described as an alternative
to existing techniques. Whether it did indeed has an improved safety profile could only be
demonstrated in a larger study.
Suggest review correct dimensions of the snare as edit suggests that this snare is 6 cm in length !
Title: A method of “Noninjecting Resection using Bipolar Soft coagulation mode; NIRBS” for
superficial non-ampullary duodenal epithelial tumor: A pilot study
Version: 6 Date: 31 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
As highlighted in my original comments, I disagree with the comment in the introduction
that present techniques (except for ESD) are high risk for removal of duodenal adenomas.
Sessile polyp preinjection and resection with cold snare or electrocautery snare really very safe,
particularly in the small mucosal defects that can be closed with clips.
This normal technique described in this pilot study can only really be described as an alternative
to existing techniques. Whether it did indeed has an improved safety profile could only be
demonstrated in a larger study.
Suggest review correct dimensions of the snare as edit suggests that this snare is 6 cm in length !
Please review this paper.
user
Title: A method of “Noninjecting Resection using Bipolar Soft coagulation mode; NIRBS” for
superficial non-ampullary duodenal epithelial tumor: A pilot study
Version: 6 Date: 31 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
As highlighted in my original comments, I disagree with the comment in the introduction
that present techniques (except for ESD) are high risk for removal of duodenal adenomas.
Sessile polyp preinjection and resection with cold snare or electrocautery snare really very safe,
particularly in the small mucosal defects that can be closed with clips.
This normal technique described in this pilot study can only really be described as an alternative
to existing techniques. Whether it did indeed has an improved safety profile could only be
demonstrated in a larger study.
Suggest review correct dimensions of the snare as edit suggests that this snare is 6 cm in length !
assistant