Title: Influencing factors and predictive model of postoperative infection in patients with
primary hepatic carcinoma
Version: 2 Date: 19 Dec 2022
Reviewer:  Takayuki Shimizu
Reviewer's report:
The authors created the new predicting nomogram for postoperative infection in patients
with HCC. I agree to evaluate postoperative patients early and to take active and effective
interventions using nomogram.
This predicting model was well done, and there was no problem in statistical method.
I ask some requirement for the authors.
Q1. The authors should add study limitation in the Discussion session.
Q2. Is there the cut-off value of points for increasing infection in your nomogram?
Q3. If you use your nomogram, how do you perform early interventions for patients with
high points of your nomogram? Could you add your consideration about this question in the
Discussion session?
Title: Influencing factors and predictive model of postoperative infection in patients with
primary hepatic carcinoma
Version: 2 Date: 19 Dec 2022
Reviewer:  Takayuki Shimizu
Reviewer's report:
The authors created the new predicting nomogram for postoperative infection in patients
with HCC. I agree to evaluate postoperative patients early and to take active and effective
interventions using nomogram.
This predicting model was well done, and there was no problem in statistical method.
I ask some requirement for the authors.
Q1. The authors should add study limitation in the Discussion session.
Q2. Is there the cut-off value of points for increasing infection in your nomogram?
Q3. If you use your nomogram, how do you perform early interventions for patients with
high points of your nomogram? Could you add your consideration about this question in the
Discussion session?
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Influencing factors and predictive model of postoperative infection in patients with
primary hepatic carcinoma
Version: 2 Date: 19 Dec 2022
Reviewer:  Takayuki Shimizu
Reviewer's report:
The authors created the new predicting nomogram for postoperative infection in patients
with HCC. I agree to evaluate postoperative patients early and to take active and effective
interventions using nomogram.
This predicting model was well done, and there was no problem in statistical method.
I ask some requirement for the authors.
Q1. The authors should add study limitation in the Discussion session.
Q2. Is there the cut-off value of points for increasing infection in your nomogram?
Q3. If you use your nomogram, how do you perform early interventions for patients with
high points of your nomogram? Could you add your consideration about this question in the
Discussion session?
assistant