Title: Application of a Novel Scoring System for Gastric Cancer Opportunistic Screening in
Hospital Visits
Version: 0 Date: 17 Feb 2022
Reviewer's report:
The authors propose a new scoring system and screening procedure for gastric cancer screening.
The study is very interesting, but there are several issues that may limit further impact.
1. The inclusion criteria are all high-risk exposure factors for gastric cancer, which may have
less effect on healthy people
2. Can you explain how to determine the cut-off values for the high, intermediate and low risk
groups
3. Whether baseline differences such as age, gender, and BMI among high-, intermediate-, and
low-risk groups can be obtained, there may be interesting findings
4. Expect more in-depth discussions on different gastric cancer types
5. The cited literature is relatively old, and it is recommended to update the latest progress articles
Title: Application of a Novel Scoring System for Gastric Cancer Opportunistic Screening in
Hospital Visits
Version: 0 Date: 17 Feb 2022
Reviewer's report:
The authors propose a new scoring system and screening procedure for gastric cancer screening.
The study is very interesting, but there are several issues that may limit further impact.
1. The inclusion criteria are all high-risk exposure factors for gastric cancer, which may have
less effect on healthy people
2. Can you explain how to determine the cut-off values for the high, intermediate and low risk
groups
3. Whether baseline differences such as age, gender, and BMI among high-, intermediate-, and
low-risk groups can be obtained, there may be interesting findings
4. Expect more in-depth discussions on different gastric cancer types
5. The cited literature is relatively old, and it is recommended to update the latest progress articles
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Application of a Novel Scoring System for Gastric Cancer Opportunistic Screening in
Hospital Visits
Version: 0 Date: 17 Feb 2022
Reviewer's report:
The authors propose a new scoring system and screening procedure for gastric cancer screening.
The study is very interesting, but there are several issues that may limit further impact.
1. The inclusion criteria are all high-risk exposure factors for gastric cancer, which may have
less effect on healthy people
2. Can you explain how to determine the cut-off values for the high, intermediate and low risk
groups
3. Whether baseline differences such as age, gender, and BMI among high-, intermediate-, and
low-risk groups can be obtained, there may be interesting findings
4. Expect more in-depth discussions on different gastric cancer types
5. The cited literature is relatively old, and it is recommended to update the latest progress articles
assistant