Title: Evaluating future risk of NAFLD in adolescents: a prediction and decision curve analysis
Version: 2 Date: 31 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
1- I believe that instead of discussion, it is a conclusion in the abstract. I suggest inserting in the
conclusion, some practical solution and applied in the clinical context.
2- Insert the term Body composition in the keywords.
3- Insert the sample power calculation in the method.
4- Regarding anthropometry, what protocol was used? What was the value of the measurement
technical error, such information is necessary.
5- Shallow discussion, all results data must be discussed, please insert the paragraphs for
discussion of each of the results. It is necessary to bring the main findings, but discuss the best
models and why they are useful.
Title: Evaluating future risk of NAFLD in adolescents: a prediction and decision curve analysis
Version: 2 Date: 31 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
1- I believe that instead of discussion, it is a conclusion in the abstract. I suggest inserting in the
conclusion, some practical solution and applied in the clinical context.
2- Insert the term Body composition in the keywords.
3- Insert the sample power calculation in the method.
4- Regarding anthropometry, what protocol was used? What was the value of the measurement
technical error, such information is necessary.
5- Shallow discussion, all results data must be discussed, please insert the paragraphs for
discussion of each of the results. It is necessary to bring the main findings, but discuss the best
models and why they are useful.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Evaluating future risk of NAFLD in adolescents: a prediction and decision curve analysis
Version: 2 Date: 31 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
1- I believe that instead of discussion, it is a conclusion in the abstract. I suggest inserting in the
conclusion, some practical solution and applied in the clinical context.
2- Insert the term Body composition in the keywords.
3- Insert the sample power calculation in the method.
4- Regarding anthropometry, what protocol was used? What was the value of the measurement
technical error, such information is necessary.
5- Shallow discussion, all results data must be discussed, please insert the paragraphs for
discussion of each of the results. It is necessary to bring the main findings, but discuss the best
models and why they are useful.
assistant