Title: Epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal cancer and advanced adenoma: a
single center experience in Jordan
Version: 3 Date: 25 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors
In your paper You evaluated the epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal polyps
to formulate an appropriate screening program.
Following my specific comments;
1) The aim of the paper is very clear.
2) The topic addressed is consistent with current literature.
3) The bibliography is in line with the topic of the article.
4) Although this article can provide useful guidance for clinical practice, a critical issue should
be addressed:
a) A correlation with the definition of adenoma detection rate
b) A reference to the possible an adenoma detection rate redefination relatively to the Jordan
population
Formulate an appropriate screening program a difficult reality to define. There are good
suggestions in the article on how to formulate an adequate screening program.
Title: Epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal cancer and advanced adenoma: a
single center experience in Jordan
Version: 3 Date: 25 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors
In your paper You evaluated the epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal polyps
to formulate an appropriate screening program.
Following my specific comments;
1) The aim of the paper is very clear.
2) The topic addressed is consistent with current literature.
3) The bibliography is in line with the topic of the article.
4) Although this article can provide useful guidance for clinical practice, a critical issue should
be addressed:
a) A correlation with the definition of adenoma detection rate
b) A reference to the possible an adenoma detection rate redefination relatively to the Jordan
population
Formulate an appropriate screening program a difficult reality to define. There are good
suggestions in the article on how to formulate an adequate screening program.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal cancer and advanced adenoma: a
single center experience in Jordan
Version: 3 Date: 25 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors
In your paper You evaluated the epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal polyps
to formulate an appropriate screening program.
Following my specific comments;
1) The aim of the paper is very clear.
2) The topic addressed is consistent with current literature.
3) The bibliography is in line with the topic of the article.
4) Although this article can provide useful guidance for clinical practice, a critical issue should
be addressed:
a) A correlation with the definition of adenoma detection rate
b) A reference to the possible an adenoma detection rate redefination relatively to the Jordan
population
Formulate an appropriate screening program a difficult reality to define. There are good
suggestions in the article on how to formulate an adequate screening program.
assistant