Title: Novel non-HDLc/HDLc Ratio for Predicting MASLD: A Cross-Sectional Study in a
Chinese Health Screening Population
Version: 3 Date: 27 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract The sentenced about the aim of the study is unfinished the eatio of nonHDL/HDL
cholesterol is related to what? It is not clear which parameters entered in multivariated analysis
In the results numerical values for statistically significant paremeters should be presented Finally
the size of the abstract could be reduced making it more dense Is the aim of the study to
define criteria of MASLD in the general population? Actually this is an interesting prespective,
because today ascreening for MASLD in the general population is thought not to be cost
effective Methods Excluded patients should be moved to the results section Once more MASLD
patients should be devided in MASLD and MetSLD patients taking into comsideration alcohol
consumption unless nonHDLc/HDLc ratio is uselesss to discriminate the two groups Statistics
Calculation of the sample size should be performed Construction of MASLD prediction models
should be described
Title: Novel non-HDLc/HDLc Ratio for Predicting MASLD: A Cross-Sectional Study in a
Chinese Health Screening Population
Version: 3 Date: 27 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract The sentenced about the aim of the study is unfinished the eatio of nonHDL/HDL
cholesterol is related to what? It is not clear which parameters entered in multivariated analysis
In the results numerical values for statistically significant paremeters should be presented Finally
the size of the abstract could be reduced making it more dense Is the aim of the study to
define criteria of MASLD in the general population? Actually this is an interesting prespective,
because today ascreening for MASLD in the general population is thought not to be cost
effective Methods Excluded patients should be moved to the results section Once more MASLD
patients should be devided in MASLD and MetSLD patients taking into comsideration alcohol
consumption unless nonHDLc/HDLc ratio is uselesss to discriminate the two groups Statistics
Calculation of the sample size should be performed Construction of MASLD prediction models
should be described
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Novel non-HDLc/HDLc Ratio for Predicting MASLD: A Cross-Sectional Study in a
Chinese Health Screening Population
Version: 3 Date: 27 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract The sentenced about the aim of the study is unfinished the eatio of nonHDL/HDL
cholesterol is related to what? It is not clear which parameters entered in multivariated analysis
In the results numerical values for statistically significant paremeters should be presented Finally
the size of the abstract could be reduced making it more dense Is the aim of the study to
define criteria of MASLD in the general population? Actually this is an interesting prespective,
because today ascreening for MASLD in the general population is thought not to be cost
effective Methods Excluded patients should be moved to the results section Once more MASLD
patients should be devided in MASLD and MetSLD patients taking into comsideration alcohol
consumption unless nonHDLc/HDLc ratio is uselesss to discriminate the two groups Statistics
Calculation of the sample size should be performed Construction of MASLD prediction models
should be described
assistant