Title: Impact of improvement of sleep disturbance on symptoms and quality of life in patients
with functional dyspepsia
Version: 0 Date: 26 Nov 2020
Reviewer's report:
REVIEWER BLIND COMMENTS TO AUTHOR:
Submission ID: 759ab808-1a2f-47a2-b3f0-0c93c56f4d70
Title: Impact of improvement of sleep disturbance on symptoms and quality of life in patients
with functional dyspepsia
Journal: BMC Gastroenterology
1) The authors did not demonstrate how they calculated the sample size.
2) Could have an effect of gender as well as menopause on the findings?
3) The study has approximately 4% of references from the last three years, none of which after
2019. Please update it.
4) The statistical tests performed by the authors are superficial. Binary logistic regression is
recommended to assess the association between the factors.
5) The figure could have been shown as a boxplot.
Title: Impact of improvement of sleep disturbance on symptoms and quality of life in patients
with functional dyspepsia
Version: 0 Date: 26 Nov 2020
Reviewer's report:
REVIEWER BLIND COMMENTS TO AUTHOR:
Submission ID: 759ab808-1a2f-47a2-b3f0-0c93c56f4d70
Title: Impact of improvement of sleep disturbance on symptoms and quality of life in patients
with functional dyspepsia
Journal: BMC Gastroenterology
1) The authors did not demonstrate how they calculated the sample size.
2) Could have an effect of gender as well as menopause on the findings?
3) The study has approximately 4% of references from the last three years, none of which after
2019. Please update it.
4) The statistical tests performed by the authors are superficial. Binary logistic regression is
recommended to assess the association between the factors.
5) The figure could have been shown as a boxplot.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Impact of improvement of sleep disturbance on symptoms and quality of life in patients
with functional dyspepsia
Version: 0 Date: 26 Nov 2020
Reviewer's report:
REVIEWER BLIND COMMENTS TO AUTHOR:
Submission ID: 759ab808-1a2f-47a2-b3f0-0c93c56f4d70
Title: Impact of improvement of sleep disturbance on symptoms and quality of life in patients
with functional dyspepsia
Journal: BMC Gastroenterology
1) The authors did not demonstrate how they calculated the sample size.
2) Could have an effect of gender as well as menopause on the findings?
3) The study has approximately 4% of references from the last three years, none of which after
2019. Please update it.
4) The statistical tests performed by the authors are superficial. Binary logistic regression is
recommended to assess the association between the factors.
5) The figure could have been shown as a boxplot.
assistant