Title: Enhanced recovery after surgery in congenital duodenal obstruction
Version: 1 Date: 11 Jul 2023
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer’s comment
This original article was explored the clinical application of enhanced recovery after surgery
(ERAS) in pediatric patients with congenital upper gastrointestinal obstruction. ERAS is an
aggressive postoperative management which should be performed as much as possible. The
most important thing in this research is the construction of the research design. In that respect,
this study provides a sufficient explanation and is worthy of evaluation. Although the number of
cases is small, I think the statistical analysis reflects a more reasonable result than studies with
an extremely large number of cases. I'd like to ask for a minor revision, so I'll list it below.
1) Table 1
Can you list the parts common to the ERAS group and the control group together without
dividing them into table cells? It's easy to understand what the two groups have in common.
2) Study subjects, Results
The inclusion/exclusion criteria are carefully written. Can you provide the diseases that were
included as a result? I think it is very important to understand which disease the results are
reflected for.
Title: Enhanced recovery after surgery in congenital duodenal obstruction
Version: 1 Date: 11 Jul 2023
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer’s comment
This original article was explored the clinical application of enhanced recovery after surgery
(ERAS) in pediatric patients with congenital upper gastrointestinal obstruction. ERAS is an
aggressive postoperative management which should be performed as much as possible. The
most important thing in this research is the construction of the research design. In that respect,
this study provides a sufficient explanation and is worthy of evaluation. Although the number of
cases is small, I think the statistical analysis reflects a more reasonable result than studies with
an extremely large number of cases. I'd like to ask for a minor revision, so I'll list it below.
1) Table 1
Can you list the parts common to the ERAS group and the control group together without
dividing them into table cells? It's easy to understand what the two groups have in common.
2) Study subjects, Results
The inclusion/exclusion criteria are carefully written. Can you provide the diseases that were
included as a result? I think it is very important to understand which disease the results are
reflected for.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Enhanced recovery after surgery in congenital duodenal obstruction
Version: 1 Date: 11 Jul 2023
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer’s comment
This original article was explored the clinical application of enhanced recovery after surgery
(ERAS) in pediatric patients with congenital upper gastrointestinal obstruction. ERAS is an
aggressive postoperative management which should be performed as much as possible. The
most important thing in this research is the construction of the research design. In that respect,
this study provides a sufficient explanation and is worthy of evaluation. Although the number of
cases is small, I think the statistical analysis reflects a more reasonable result than studies with
an extremely large number of cases. I'd like to ask for a minor revision, so I'll list it below.
1) Table 1
Can you list the parts common to the ERAS group and the control group together without
dividing them into table cells? It's easy to understand what the two groups have in common.
2) Study subjects, Results
The inclusion/exclusion criteria are carefully written. Can you provide the diseases that were
included as a result? I think it is very important to understand which disease the results are
reflected for.
assistant