Title: Clinical characteristics of MASLD/MetALD/MAFLD/NAFLD and the relative risk
analysis on metabolic disorders
Version: 2 Date: 12 Apr 2025
Reviewer's report:
This an interesting study comparing definitions of steatitic liver disease. It shows a peculiar
dysmetabolism segregation according to different definition of the syndrome.
It can have significant prognostic and preventive impact.
However, I have one criticism about the nature of the study: is it a retrospective ? on an existing
database ? This can bias the significance of results ? Please, discuss on this.
Title: Clinical characteristics of MASLD/MetALD/MAFLD/NAFLD and the relative risk
analysis on metabolic disorders
Version: 2 Date: 12 Apr 2025
Reviewer's report:
This an interesting study comparing definitions of steatitic liver disease. It shows a peculiar
dysmetabolism segregation according to different definition of the syndrome.
It can have significant prognostic and preventive impact.
However, I have one criticism about the nature of the study: is it a retrospective ? on an existing
database ? This can bias the significance of results ? Please, discuss on this.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinical characteristics of MASLD/MetALD/MAFLD/NAFLD and the relative risk
analysis on metabolic disorders
Version: 2 Date: 12 Apr 2025
Reviewer's report:
This an interesting study comparing definitions of steatitic liver disease. It shows a peculiar
dysmetabolism segregation according to different definition of the syndrome.
It can have significant prognostic and preventive impact.
However, I have one criticism about the nature of the study: is it a retrospective ? on an existing
database ? This can bias the significance of results ? Please, discuss on this.
assistant