Title: Prediction of post-ESD Esophageal Stricture by a Nomogram and Risk Factor analysis
of Ineffective Oral Steroids Prophylaxis
Version: 3 Date: 25 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract: turning point of the nomogram should be given Also indication for steroid use should
be included Methods Indication for steroids should be defined ( what the size of big lesions?)
Also glucocorticosteroid receptor expressions in the pathology report is rather vague Patient
demographics should be given Authors should explain why they selected 3/4 of lumen diameter
for their model and then 7/8 for steroid ineffectiveness Results of the univariated analysis should
be also provided before presenting results of multivariate analysis Percentages should be given
apart from crude numbers  Risk factors for stenosis should be calculated separately Discussion
should be adapted accordingly
Title: Prediction of post-ESD Esophageal Stricture by a Nomogram and Risk Factor analysis
of Ineffective Oral Steroids Prophylaxis
Version: 3 Date: 25 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract: turning point of the nomogram should be given Also indication for steroid use should
be included Methods Indication for steroids should be defined ( what the size of big lesions?)
Also glucocorticosteroid receptor expressions in the pathology report is rather vague Patient
demographics should be given Authors should explain why they selected 3/4 of lumen diameter
for their model and then 7/8 for steroid ineffectiveness Results of the univariated analysis should
be also provided before presenting results of multivariate analysis Percentages should be given
apart from crude numbers  Risk factors for stenosis should be calculated separately Discussion
should be adapted accordingly
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Prediction of post-ESD Esophageal Stricture by a Nomogram and Risk Factor analysis
of Ineffective Oral Steroids Prophylaxis
Version: 3 Date: 25 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract: turning point of the nomogram should be given Also indication for steroid use should
be included Methods Indication for steroids should be defined ( what the size of big lesions?)
Also glucocorticosteroid receptor expressions in the pathology report is rather vague Patient
demographics should be given Authors should explain why they selected 3/4 of lumen diameter
for their model and then 7/8 for steroid ineffectiveness Results of the univariated analysis should
be also provided before presenting results of multivariate analysis Percentages should be given
apart from crude numbers  Risk factors for stenosis should be calculated separately Discussion
should be adapted accordingly
assistant