Title: Study on the factors influencing the prognosis after perianal abscess surgery
Version: 1 Date: 29 Mar 2023
Reviewer's report:
The study focuses on  the influence of clinical characteristics and diagnosis and treatment
methods of perianal abscess on postoperative recurrence or formation of anal fistula. Anal fistula
is a  disease prone to relapse and the research point is interesting. However, there are some
fundamental problems needed to be solved.
1. Surgery plays a critical role in curing anal fistula, surgery related factors such as surgeon
experience, details of surgery approach were not included in the analysis.
2. The study design lacks of innovation and the conclusion seems not different from previous
studies.
3. The figures and tables are redundant. Some figures and tables are no need to be displayed,
while the important information like demographic data were missing.
Title: Study on the factors influencing the prognosis after perianal abscess surgery
Version: 1 Date: 29 Mar 2023
Reviewer's report:
The study focuses on  the influence of clinical characteristics and diagnosis and treatment
methods of perianal abscess on postoperative recurrence or formation of anal fistula. Anal fistula
is a  disease prone to relapse and the research point is interesting. However, there are some
fundamental problems needed to be solved.
1. Surgery plays a critical role in curing anal fistula, surgery related factors such as surgeon
experience, details of surgery approach were not included in the analysis.
2. The study design lacks of innovation and the conclusion seems not different from previous
studies.
3. The figures and tables are redundant. Some figures and tables are no need to be displayed,
while the important information like demographic data were missing.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Study on the factors influencing the prognosis after perianal abscess surgery
Version: 1 Date: 29 Mar 2023
Reviewer's report:
The study focuses on  the influence of clinical characteristics and diagnosis and treatment
methods of perianal abscess on postoperative recurrence or formation of anal fistula. Anal fistula
is a  disease prone to relapse and the research point is interesting. However, there are some
fundamental problems needed to be solved.
1. Surgery plays a critical role in curing anal fistula, surgery related factors such as surgeon
experience, details of surgery approach were not included in the analysis.
2. The study design lacks of innovation and the conclusion seems not different from previous
studies.
3. The figures and tables are redundant. Some figures and tables are no need to be displayed,
while the important information like demographic data were missing.
assistant