Reviewer's report
Title:Online follow-up of individuals with gastroesophageal reflux disease using
a patient-reported outcomes instrument: results of an observational study
Version: 2Date:11 August 2013
Reviewer: ALEKSANDAR M NAGORNI
Reviewer's report:
Some Minor Essential Revisions have to be done:
1. Second page-At the beginning of new sentence in the 6th line of results
authors have to correct 55% in Fifty-five percent.
2. Citation of references 3 and 12, need correction and true citation as The New
England Journal of Medicine.
3.Correct citation of references 6,10,15,16,17,21,22,23,24,25 is Alimentary
Pharmacology&Therapeutics or shorten Aliment Pharmacol&Ther.
4. In relation of policy of citation of BMC Gastroenterology for multiple authors, if
the number of citated authors is 10, then authors of article are correctly do that.
In the case the number of authors are 4 or 6 than authors need to change
corrections in a few references.
5. In reference number 4 authors citated French name of Canadian Journal of
Gastroenterology as English. English name is sufficient.
6. In reference 2, after Melton LJ, 3rd need to delete.
7. In references 7 and 19 after volume there are only first page of article.
8. In reference 7 After BMC G in gastroenterology need to be in blocj letter.
9.Citation of reference 18 is not complete. Fail number of pages.
10. Reference number 28 is not complete and need to be changed with addition
of netherlands as language of reference.
11. In references 8 and 19, first block letter in the name of references need to be
done.
12. The same corrections should be done in references 9,14, and 26.
Level of interest: An article of importance in its field
Quality of written English: Acceptable
Statistical review: No, the manuscript does not need to be seen by a
statistician.
Declaration of competing interests:
'I declare that I have no competing interests' .
Reviewer's report
Title:Online follow-up of individuals with gastroesophageal reflux disease using
a patient-reported outcomes instrument: results of an observational study
Version: 2Date:11 August 2013
Reviewer: ALEKSANDAR M NAGORNI
Reviewer's report:
Some Minor Essential Revisions have to be done:
1. Second page-At the beginning of new sentence in the 6th line of results
authors have to correct 55% in Fifty-five percent.
2. Citation of references 3 and 12, need correction and true citation as The New
England Journal of Medicine.
3.Correct citation of references 6,10,15,16,17,21,22,23,24,25 is Alimentary
Pharmacology&Therapeutics or shorten Aliment Pharmacol&Ther.
4. In relation of policy of citation of BMC Gastroenterology for multiple authors, if
the number of citated authors is 10, then authors of article are correctly do that.
In the case the number of authors are 4 or 6 than authors need to change
corrections in a few references.
5. In reference number 4 authors citated French name of Canadian Journal of
Gastroenterology as English. English name is sufficient.
6. In reference 2, after Melton LJ, 3rd need to delete.
7. In references 7 and 19 after volume there are only first page of article.
8. In reference 7 After BMC G in gastroenterology need to be in blocj letter.
9.Citation of reference 18 is not complete. Fail number of pages.
10. Reference number 28 is not complete and need to be changed with addition
of netherlands as language of reference.
11. In references 8 and 19, first block letter in the name of references need to be
done.
12. The same corrections should be done in references 9,14, and 26.
Level of interest: An article of importance in its field
Quality of written English: Acceptable
Statistical review: No, the manuscript does not need to be seen by a
statistician.
Declaration of competing interests:
'I declare that I have no competing interests' .
Please review this paper.
user
Reviewer's report
Title:Online follow-up of individuals with gastroesophageal reflux disease using
a patient-reported outcomes instrument: results of an observational study
Version: 2Date:11 August 2013
Reviewer: ALEKSANDAR M NAGORNI
Reviewer's report:
Some Minor Essential Revisions have to be done:
1. Second page-At the beginning of new sentence in the 6th line of results
authors have to correct 55% in Fifty-five percent.
2. Citation of references 3 and 12, need correction and true citation as The New
England Journal of Medicine.
3.Correct citation of references 6,10,15,16,17,21,22,23,24,25 is Alimentary
Pharmacology&Therapeutics or shorten Aliment Pharmacol&Ther.
4. In relation of policy of citation of BMC Gastroenterology for multiple authors, if
the number of citated authors is 10, then authors of article are correctly do that.
In the case the number of authors are 4 or 6 than authors need to change
corrections in a few references.
5. In reference number 4 authors citated French name of Canadian Journal of
Gastroenterology as English. English name is sufficient.
6. In reference 2, after Melton LJ, 3rd need to delete.
7. In references 7 and 19 after volume there are only first page of article.
8. In reference 7 After BMC G in gastroenterology need to be in blocj letter.
9.Citation of reference 18 is not complete. Fail number of pages.
10. Reference number 28 is not complete and need to be changed with addition
of netherlands as language of reference.
11. In references 8 and 19, first block letter in the name of references need to be
done.
12. The same corrections should be done in references 9,14, and 26.
Level of interest: An article of importance in its field
Quality of written English: Acceptable
Statistical review: No, the manuscript does not need to be seen by a
statistician.
Declaration of competing interests:
'I declare that I have no competing interests' .
assistant