Title: Clinical significance of reactive thrombocytosis in the course of acute pancreatitis
Version: 0 Date: 09 Feb 2023
Reviewer's report:
Clinical significance of reactive thrombocytosis in the course of acute pancreatitis titled
manuscript is carefully evaluated. My comments are listed as below.
1. Title: it is concise and relevant
2. Abstract: it is a well written summary of the manuscript
3. introduction: Objectives of the study are clearly mentioned however, background data about
studied parameters is not adequate. Acute pancreatitis is associated with significant amount of
inflammation (Pancreas, 2016, 45.8: 1120-1125.). On the other hand, platelet indices, especially
mean platelet volume have been reported to be related with inflammatory conditions such
as gastrointestinal disorders ( Iranian Journal of Colorectal Research, 2022, 10.3.),  hepatitis
(European journal of gastroenterology & hepatology, 2022, 34.3: 324-327.), frailty (Clinical
Diabetology, 2022, 11.2: 119-126.), hypothyroidism (National Journal of Health Sciences, 2021,
6.1: 7-10.), and coronary conditions (Arquivos Brasileiros de Cardiologia, 2019, 113: 71-76).
Please improve the background
4. Methodology: expressed well. statistics are correct but authors did not mention which
normality test was applied to the study variables.
5. Results:Presentation of the results is adequate
6. Discussion: fairly discussed. Yet, I encourage authors to comment on clinical usage of the
study results even with few words.
7. Conclusions: justified
Title: Clinical significance of reactive thrombocytosis in the course of acute pancreatitis
Version: 0 Date: 09 Feb 2023
Reviewer's report:
Clinical significance of reactive thrombocytosis in the course of acute pancreatitis titled
manuscript is carefully evaluated. My comments are listed as below.
1. Title: it is concise and relevant
2. Abstract: it is a well written summary of the manuscript
3. introduction: Objectives of the study are clearly mentioned however, background data about
studied parameters is not adequate. Acute pancreatitis is associated with significant amount of
inflammation (Pancreas, 2016, 45.8: 1120-1125.). On the other hand, platelet indices, especially
mean platelet volume have been reported to be related with inflammatory conditions such
as gastrointestinal disorders ( Iranian Journal of Colorectal Research, 2022, 10.3.),  hepatitis
(European journal of gastroenterology & hepatology, 2022, 34.3: 324-327.), frailty (Clinical
Diabetology, 2022, 11.2: 119-126.), hypothyroidism (National Journal of Health Sciences, 2021,
6.1: 7-10.), and coronary conditions (Arquivos Brasileiros de Cardiologia, 2019, 113: 71-76).
Please improve the background
4. Methodology: expressed well. statistics are correct but authors did not mention which
normality test was applied to the study variables.
5. Results:Presentation of the results is adequate
6. Discussion: fairly discussed. Yet, I encourage authors to comment on clinical usage of the
study results even with few words.
7. Conclusions: justified
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinical significance of reactive thrombocytosis in the course of acute pancreatitis
Version: 0 Date: 09 Feb 2023
Reviewer's report:
Clinical significance of reactive thrombocytosis in the course of acute pancreatitis titled
manuscript is carefully evaluated. My comments are listed as below.
1. Title: it is concise and relevant
2. Abstract: it is a well written summary of the manuscript
3. introduction: Objectives of the study are clearly mentioned however, background data about
studied parameters is not adequate. Acute pancreatitis is associated with significant amount of
inflammation (Pancreas, 2016, 45.8: 1120-1125.). On the other hand, platelet indices, especially
mean platelet volume have been reported to be related with inflammatory conditions such
as gastrointestinal disorders ( Iranian Journal of Colorectal Research, 2022, 10.3.),  hepatitis
(European journal of gastroenterology & hepatology, 2022, 34.3: 324-327.), frailty (Clinical
Diabetology, 2022, 11.2: 119-126.), hypothyroidism (National Journal of Health Sciences, 2021,
6.1: 7-10.), and coronary conditions (Arquivos Brasileiros de Cardiologia, 2019, 113: 71-76).
Please improve the background
4. Methodology: expressed well. statistics are correct but authors did not mention which
normality test was applied to the study variables.
5. Results:Presentation of the results is adequate
6. Discussion: fairly discussed. Yet, I encourage authors to comment on clinical usage of the
study results even with few words.
7. Conclusions: justified
assistant