Title: Epidemiology, risk factors, diagnosis, and treatment of intra-abdominal traumatic
neuromas - a narrative review
Version: 0 Date: 01 Aug 2023
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript presents a case series both from the authors' center and from the   literature
focused on an intraabdominal traumatic neuroma, a really rare pathology of abdominal cavity.
The article observes epidemiology of TN, most frequents clinical characteristics, risk factors,
and diagnostic and treatment approaches. It is written with good scientific English language,
divided by subheadings.
Anyway, there are some issues that are need to be clarified.
It is not clear if the statical analysis of the presented data was performed. Authors describe some
statical information, so was it obtained from the literature data only?  If the authors performed
any statical analysis, please, describe it in the manuscript.
There are two subgroups of cases - literature data and clinical data of the authors' medical center.
About the cases from the authors' medical center-   did the patients give the consent? Please note
it in the appropriate section.
What was the longest follow-up period in the asymptomatic patients? Were there any clinical
changes during the follow up?
Please, add the "Conclusions" section with several sentences with the main findings of your
article and  possible perspectives in TN diagnosis and treatment.
Title: Epidemiology, risk factors, diagnosis, and treatment of intra-abdominal traumatic
neuromas - a narrative review
Version: 0 Date: 01 Aug 2023
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript presents a case series both from the authors' center and from the   literature
focused on an intraabdominal traumatic neuroma, a really rare pathology of abdominal cavity.
The article observes epidemiology of TN, most frequents clinical characteristics, risk factors,
and diagnostic and treatment approaches. It is written with good scientific English language,
divided by subheadings.
Anyway, there are some issues that are need to be clarified.
It is not clear if the statical analysis of the presented data was performed. Authors describe some
statical information, so was it obtained from the literature data only?  If the authors performed
any statical analysis, please, describe it in the manuscript.
There are two subgroups of cases - literature data and clinical data of the authors' medical center.
About the cases from the authors' medical center-   did the patients give the consent? Please note
it in the appropriate section.
What was the longest follow-up period in the asymptomatic patients? Were there any clinical
changes during the follow up?
Please, add the "Conclusions" section with several sentences with the main findings of your
article and  possible perspectives in TN diagnosis and treatment.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Epidemiology, risk factors, diagnosis, and treatment of intra-abdominal traumatic
neuromas - a narrative review
Version: 0 Date: 01 Aug 2023
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript presents a case series both from the authors' center and from the   literature
focused on an intraabdominal traumatic neuroma, a really rare pathology of abdominal cavity.
The article observes epidemiology of TN, most frequents clinical characteristics, risk factors,
and diagnostic and treatment approaches. It is written with good scientific English language,
divided by subheadings.
Anyway, there are some issues that are need to be clarified.
It is not clear if the statical analysis of the presented data was performed. Authors describe some
statical information, so was it obtained from the literature data only?  If the authors performed
any statical analysis, please, describe it in the manuscript.
There are two subgroups of cases - literature data and clinical data of the authors' medical center.
About the cases from the authors' medical center-   did the patients give the consent? Please note
it in the appropriate section.
What was the longest follow-up period in the asymptomatic patients? Were there any clinical
changes during the follow up?
Please, add the "Conclusions" section with several sentences with the main findings of your
article and  possible perspectives in TN diagnosis and treatment.
assistant