Title: Timing  and Other Factors Influencing Short#Term Outcomes of Endoscopic
Transpapillary Gallbladder Drainage for Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 20 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting paper. In daily clinical practice, we experienced that ETGBD performed
after PTGBD has a higher success rate than ETGBD performed early. The definitions of early
and delayed periods are unclear, so please define them. Please state the number of cases in which
PTGBD or PTGBA was performed before ETGBD in the patient background. Many of the
delayed ETGBDs in this paper had prior PTGBD (or PTGBA), so it is difficult to conclude that
this is an evaluation of delayed ETGBD alone. Please reevaluate the analysis of ETGBD failure
in a multivariate analysis, including a factor that PTGBD (or PTGBA) was not performed. If
prior PTGBD (or PTGBA) can be listed as a factor in ETGBD success, please change the title.
Title: Timing  and Other Factors Influencing Short#Term Outcomes of Endoscopic
Transpapillary Gallbladder Drainage for Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 20 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting paper. In daily clinical practice, we experienced that ETGBD performed
after PTGBD has a higher success rate than ETGBD performed early. The definitions of early
and delayed periods are unclear, so please define them. Please state the number of cases in which
PTGBD or PTGBA was performed before ETGBD in the patient background. Many of the
delayed ETGBDs in this paper had prior PTGBD (or PTGBA), so it is difficult to conclude that
this is an evaluation of delayed ETGBD alone. Please reevaluate the analysis of ETGBD failure
in a multivariate analysis, including a factor that PTGBD (or PTGBA) was not performed. If
prior PTGBD (or PTGBA) can be listed as a factor in ETGBD success, please change the title.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Timing  and Other Factors Influencing Short#Term Outcomes of Endoscopic
Transpapillary Gallbladder Drainage for Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 20 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting paper. In daily clinical practice, we experienced that ETGBD performed
after PTGBD has a higher success rate than ETGBD performed early. The definitions of early
and delayed periods are unclear, so please define them. Please state the number of cases in which
PTGBD or PTGBA was performed before ETGBD in the patient background. Many of the
delayed ETGBDs in this paper had prior PTGBD (or PTGBA), so it is difficult to conclude that
this is an evaluation of delayed ETGBD alone. Please reevaluate the analysis of ETGBD failure
in a multivariate analysis, including a factor that PTGBD (or PTGBA) was not performed. If
prior PTGBD (or PTGBA) can be listed as a factor in ETGBD success, please change the title.
assistant