Title: Analysis of influencing factors and nursing strategies for enteral nutrition patients
complicated with refeeding syndrome in ICU
Version: 1 Date: 14 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
The article “Analysis of influencing factors and nursing strategies in patients with enteral
nutrition complicated by re-feeding syndrome in the ICU” presents the surprising conclusion
that refeeding syndrome (RF) was common in the ICU in critically ill patients fed with enteral
nutrition.
However, most studies have shown that:
RF is usually associated with pure anabolism and deficit in intracellular mineral uptake, which
is a rare situation in ICU patients
RF is less common in patients on enteral nutrition, because it is very difficult to achieve a positive
result with enteral nutrition alone in ICU conditions.
However, the article has many pitfalls.
This is a retrospective work.
The diagnostic criteria for RF are not characterized.
The amount and form of energy (carbohydrates and lipids) and minerals during enteral nutrition
are not described.
Was the composition of the enteral nutrition the same in the patients?
In its current form, the article cannot be published because the results are not sufficiently
documented, which may lead to their misinterpretation.
Title: Analysis of influencing factors and nursing strategies for enteral nutrition patients
complicated with refeeding syndrome in ICU
Version: 1 Date: 14 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
The article “Analysis of influencing factors and nursing strategies in patients with enteral
nutrition complicated by re-feeding syndrome in the ICU” presents the surprising conclusion
that refeeding syndrome (RF) was common in the ICU in critically ill patients fed with enteral
nutrition.
However, most studies have shown that:
RF is usually associated with pure anabolism and deficit in intracellular mineral uptake, which
is a rare situation in ICU patients
RF is less common in patients on enteral nutrition, because it is very difficult to achieve a positive
result with enteral nutrition alone in ICU conditions.
However, the article has many pitfalls.
This is a retrospective work.
The diagnostic criteria for RF are not characterized.
The amount and form of energy (carbohydrates and lipids) and minerals during enteral nutrition
are not described.
Was the composition of the enteral nutrition the same in the patients?
In its current form, the article cannot be published because the results are not sufficiently
documented, which may lead to their misinterpretation.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Analysis of influencing factors and nursing strategies for enteral nutrition patients
complicated with refeeding syndrome in ICU
Version: 1 Date: 14 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
The article “Analysis of influencing factors and nursing strategies in patients with enteral
nutrition complicated by re-feeding syndrome in the ICU” presents the surprising conclusion
that refeeding syndrome (RF) was common in the ICU in critically ill patients fed with enteral
nutrition.
However, most studies have shown that:
RF is usually associated with pure anabolism and deficit in intracellular mineral uptake, which
is a rare situation in ICU patients
RF is less common in patients on enteral nutrition, because it is very difficult to achieve a positive
result with enteral nutrition alone in ICU conditions.
However, the article has many pitfalls.
This is a retrospective work.
The diagnostic criteria for RF are not characterized.
The amount and form of energy (carbohydrates and lipids) and minerals during enteral nutrition
are not described.
Was the composition of the enteral nutrition the same in the patients?
In its current form, the article cannot be published because the results are not sufficiently
documented, which may lead to their misinterpretation.
assistant