Title: Can Proximal Gastrectomy with Double-Tract Reconstruction Replace Total
Gastrectomy? a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity score-matched
studies
Version: 0 Date: 20 Jun 2024
Reviewer:  Paolo Morgagni
Reviewer's report:
The study Can Proximal Gastrectomy with Double-Tract Reconstruction Replace Total
Gastrectomy? a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity score-matched
studies From Guangxu Zhu is a good, well presented study on an interesting new solution to an
old problem. I don't have great suggestions to improve what has been done , but in discussion,
authors must refrase the paragraph, starting with : How to ensure the safety of the tumor and
determine the best resection range mainly includes two aspects: "margin distance" and "lymph
node  dissection." Who said this? What references? There is no doubt on this topic …. But it
is not supported by this study. Generally and correctly, authors affirm in the other paragraphs...
…. this is our study conclusion…This is a possible meaning …. These are our suggestions. In
this part, in particular, you may say there is no difference in margins, no difference in survival,
…..  ans so  this technique may be proposed. Moreover, please add some more evidence on this
topic, especially on stage , infiltrative, and signed ring cells, which are always not considered,
and if possible on undifferentiated . Please also say something about specific distances.
Title: Can Proximal Gastrectomy with Double-Tract Reconstruction Replace Total
Gastrectomy? a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity score-matched
studies
Version: 0 Date: 20 Jun 2024
Reviewer:  Paolo Morgagni
Reviewer's report:
The study Can Proximal Gastrectomy with Double-Tract Reconstruction Replace Total
Gastrectomy? a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity score-matched
studies From Guangxu Zhu is a good, well presented study on an interesting new solution to an
old problem. I don't have great suggestions to improve what has been done , but in discussion,
authors must refrase the paragraph, starting with : How to ensure the safety of the tumor and
determine the best resection range mainly includes two aspects: "margin distance" and "lymph
node  dissection." Who said this? What references? There is no doubt on this topic …. But it
is not supported by this study. Generally and correctly, authors affirm in the other paragraphs...
…. this is our study conclusion…This is a possible meaning …. These are our suggestions. In
this part, in particular, you may say there is no difference in margins, no difference in survival,
…..  ans so  this technique may be proposed. Moreover, please add some more evidence on this
topic, especially on stage , infiltrative, and signed ring cells, which are always not considered,
and if possible on undifferentiated . Please also say something about specific distances.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Can Proximal Gastrectomy with Double-Tract Reconstruction Replace Total
Gastrectomy? a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity score-matched
studies
Version: 0 Date: 20 Jun 2024
Reviewer:  Paolo Morgagni
Reviewer's report:
The study Can Proximal Gastrectomy with Double-Tract Reconstruction Replace Total
Gastrectomy? a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and propensity score-matched
studies From Guangxu Zhu is a good, well presented study on an interesting new solution to an
old problem. I don't have great suggestions to improve what has been done , but in discussion,
authors must refrase the paragraph, starting with : How to ensure the safety of the tumor and
determine the best resection range mainly includes two aspects: "margin distance" and "lymph
node  dissection." Who said this? What references? There is no doubt on this topic …. But it
is not supported by this study. Generally and correctly, authors affirm in the other paragraphs...
…. this is our study conclusion…This is a possible meaning …. These are our suggestions. In
this part, in particular, you may say there is no difference in margins, no difference in survival,
…..  ans so  this technique may be proposed. Moreover, please add some more evidence on this
topic, especially on stage , infiltrative, and signed ring cells, which are always not considered,
and if possible on undifferentiated . Please also say something about specific distances.
assistant