Title: Usefulness of discharge standards in outpatients undergoing sedative endoscopy: a
propensity score-matched study of the modified post-anesthetic discharge scoring system and
the modified Aldrete score
Version: 3 Date: 25 Sep 2022
Reviewer's report:
This research revealed that "Patients assessed by the modified Aldrete score were allowed
to discharge earlier than those assessed by the MPADSS. However, a patient’s level of
consciousness should be assessed carefully when using the modified Aldrete score."
This  study is  very meaningful#but there are still several questions remain to to be answered:
(1) Sample size calculation is an essential item. How does the researchers identifie and calculate
the required sample size? Does the current sample size is sufficient to indicate the reliability of
the study's conclusions?
(2)The references are relatively old, and the authoritative literature in the past three years is
rarely cited.
Title: Usefulness of discharge standards in outpatients undergoing sedative endoscopy: a
propensity score-matched study of the modified post-anesthetic discharge scoring system and
the modified Aldrete score
Version: 3 Date: 25 Sep 2022
Reviewer's report:
This research revealed that "Patients assessed by the modified Aldrete score were allowed
to discharge earlier than those assessed by the MPADSS. However, a patient’s level of
consciousness should be assessed carefully when using the modified Aldrete score."
This  study is  very meaningful#but there are still several questions remain to to be answered:
(1) Sample size calculation is an essential item. How does the researchers identifie and calculate
the required sample size? Does the current sample size is sufficient to indicate the reliability of
the study's conclusions?
(2)The references are relatively old, and the authoritative literature in the past three years is
rarely cited.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Usefulness of discharge standards in outpatients undergoing sedative endoscopy: a
propensity score-matched study of the modified post-anesthetic discharge scoring system and
the modified Aldrete score
Version: 3 Date: 25 Sep 2022
Reviewer's report:
This research revealed that "Patients assessed by the modified Aldrete score were allowed
to discharge earlier than those assessed by the MPADSS. However, a patient’s level of
consciousness should be assessed carefully when using the modified Aldrete score."
This  study is  very meaningful#but there are still several questions remain to to be answered:
(1) Sample size calculation is an essential item. How does the researchers identifie and calculate
the required sample size? Does the current sample size is sufficient to indicate the reliability of
the study's conclusions?
(2)The references are relatively old, and the authoritative literature in the past three years is
rarely cited.
assistant