Title: Triglyceride glucose waist circumference and Non alcoholic fatty liver disease: a
systematic review and meta analysis
Version: 0 Date: 25 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your submission. The article demonstrates a comprehensive analysis, and the
methodology is well-structured. However, some aspects of the manuscript require attention to
enhance its clarity and overall impact.
1. In the introduction section, it is imperative to include more recent studies to mention the
prevalence and burden of NAFLD. A recent meta-analysis published in 2024 offers updated data
on the global prevalence of NAFLD.
2. Although you’ve outlined the potential mechanisms linking TyG-WC, insulin resistance, and
NAFLD, a concise illustration would greatly improve the clarity of these concepts.
3. In the Figure 5, the terms “control” and “experimental” are not appropriate for this study’s
design. I advise revising these labels to better align with the study’s methodology.
Title: Triglyceride glucose waist circumference and Non alcoholic fatty liver disease: a
systematic review and meta analysis
Version: 0 Date: 25 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your submission. The article demonstrates a comprehensive analysis, and the
methodology is well-structured. However, some aspects of the manuscript require attention to
enhance its clarity and overall impact.
1. In the introduction section, it is imperative to include more recent studies to mention the
prevalence and burden of NAFLD. A recent meta-analysis published in 2024 offers updated data
on the global prevalence of NAFLD.
2. Although you’ve outlined the potential mechanisms linking TyG-WC, insulin resistance, and
NAFLD, a concise illustration would greatly improve the clarity of these concepts.
3. In the Figure 5, the terms “control” and “experimental” are not appropriate for this study’s
design. I advise revising these labels to better align with the study’s methodology.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Triglyceride glucose waist circumference and Non alcoholic fatty liver disease: a
systematic review and meta analysis
Version: 0 Date: 25 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your submission. The article demonstrates a comprehensive analysis, and the
methodology is well-structured. However, some aspects of the manuscript require attention to
enhance its clarity and overall impact.
1. In the introduction section, it is imperative to include more recent studies to mention the
prevalence and burden of NAFLD. A recent meta-analysis published in 2024 offers updated data
on the global prevalence of NAFLD.
2. Although you’ve outlined the potential mechanisms linking TyG-WC, insulin resistance, and
NAFLD, a concise illustration would greatly improve the clarity of these concepts.
3. In the Figure 5, the terms “control” and “experimental” are not appropriate for this study’s
design. I advise revising these labels to better align with the study’s methodology.
assistant