Title: The Association between Non- and Pro-Healthy Diet Indices and the Risk of Colorectal
Cancer: A Case-Control Study
Version: 0 Date: 01 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Because in the majority of patients colonic carcinoma derives as a result of the evolution of an
underlined polyp time frame of the study is important and should be defined In a rectrospective
study going back several years ago even more than a decade before is rather unreliable  the same
drawback is applicable in methods section Methods Inclusion and exclusio criteria should be
defined in detail (underlined comorbidities, bowel inflammation)  Also the definition of controls
is rather vague since diet can influence may diagnostic entities  Demographic and clinical data
recorded should be decribed in detail Numerical values belong to the results section and should
moved there How did authors secured that diet has not changed because of cancer existance
Results All significant risk factors after multivariated analysis should be presented in the text
Title: The Association between Non- and Pro-Healthy Diet Indices and the Risk of Colorectal
Cancer: A Case-Control Study
Version: 0 Date: 01 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Because in the majority of patients colonic carcinoma derives as a result of the evolution of an
underlined polyp time frame of the study is important and should be defined In a rectrospective
study going back several years ago even more than a decade before is rather unreliable  the same
drawback is applicable in methods section Methods Inclusion and exclusio criteria should be
defined in detail (underlined comorbidities, bowel inflammation)  Also the definition of controls
is rather vague since diet can influence may diagnostic entities  Demographic and clinical data
recorded should be decribed in detail Numerical values belong to the results section and should
moved there How did authors secured that diet has not changed because of cancer existance
Results All significant risk factors after multivariated analysis should be presented in the text
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The Association between Non- and Pro-Healthy Diet Indices and the Risk of Colorectal
Cancer: A Case-Control Study
Version: 0 Date: 01 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Because in the majority of patients colonic carcinoma derives as a result of the evolution of an
underlined polyp time frame of the study is important and should be defined In a rectrospective
study going back several years ago even more than a decade before is rather unreliable  the same
drawback is applicable in methods section Methods Inclusion and exclusio criteria should be
defined in detail (underlined comorbidities, bowel inflammation)  Also the definition of controls
is rather vague since diet can influence may diagnostic entities  Demographic and clinical data
recorded should be decribed in detail Numerical values belong to the results section and should
moved there How did authors secured that diet has not changed because of cancer existance
Results All significant risk factors after multivariated analysis should be presented in the text
assistant