Title: Prediction of injury localization in preoperative patients with gastrointestinal perforation:
A multiomics model analysis
Version: 1 Date: 19 Nov 2023
Reviewer:  Kenji Nakamura
Reviewer's report:
The authors created a prediction model for the perforation site, severity and cost, validated it,
and reported its usefulness.
This manuscript is interesting; however, it seems to be required some revisions.
Major
1) An inappropriate abbreviation appears for the first time in the abstract.
2) Introduction is too long.
3) Please indicate the criteria for ICU admission.
4) It is unclear what Figures 3 and 4 are comparing. What does "Ts patient" mean?
5) The explanation of the legend in Figure 9 is insufficient.
6) I think a and b are reversed in Figure 10.
7) Please further consider the limitations.
8) Regarding the conclusion, can this study mention the prediction of patient prognosis?
Minor
1) There are many spacing errors.
2) The red arrows in Figure 2 are the same arrows used for different parts, so please change them.
3) Please write the abbreviations in Table1.
Title: Prediction of injury localization in preoperative patients with gastrointestinal perforation:
A multiomics model analysis
Version: 1 Date: 19 Nov 2023
Reviewer:  Kenji Nakamura
Reviewer's report:
The authors created a prediction model for the perforation site, severity and cost, validated it,
and reported its usefulness.
This manuscript is interesting; however, it seems to be required some revisions.
Major
1) An inappropriate abbreviation appears for the first time in the abstract.
2) Introduction is too long.
3) Please indicate the criteria for ICU admission.
4) It is unclear what Figures 3 and 4 are comparing. What does "Ts patient" mean?
5) The explanation of the legend in Figure 9 is insufficient.
6) I think a and b are reversed in Figure 10.
7) Please further consider the limitations.
8) Regarding the conclusion, can this study mention the prediction of patient prognosis?
Minor
1) There are many spacing errors.
2) The red arrows in Figure 2 are the same arrows used for different parts, so please change them.
3) Please write the abbreviations in Table1.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Prediction of injury localization in preoperative patients with gastrointestinal perforation:
A multiomics model analysis
Version: 1 Date: 19 Nov 2023
Reviewer:  Kenji Nakamura
Reviewer's report:
The authors created a prediction model for the perforation site, severity and cost, validated it,
and reported its usefulness.
This manuscript is interesting; however, it seems to be required some revisions.
Major
1) An inappropriate abbreviation appears for the first time in the abstract.
2) Introduction is too long.
3) Please indicate the criteria for ICU admission.
4) It is unclear what Figures 3 and 4 are comparing. What does "Ts patient" mean?
5) The explanation of the legend in Figure 9 is insufficient.
6) I think a and b are reversed in Figure 10.
7) Please further consider the limitations.
8) Regarding the conclusion, can this study mention the prediction of patient prognosis?
Minor
1) There are many spacing errors.
2) The red arrows in Figure 2 are the same arrows used for different parts, so please change them.
3) Please write the abbreviations in Table1.
assistant