Title: Clinicopathological features of early-onset colorectal cancer in Japanese patients: A
single-center retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I believe the authors' responses have addressed most of my concerns (except for a few issues
that are unavoidable due to the study design and the problems it aims to solve).
However, the quality of the figures remains concerning, particularly regarding pixel resolution,
font issues, and inconsistencies in font capitalization. As a high-level journal, such figure quality
should not be acceptable. I strongly recommend that the authors make the necessary adjustments.
Once these issues are resolved, I suggest that this article be accepted for publication in BMC
Gastroenterology.
Title: Clinicopathological features of early-onset colorectal cancer in Japanese patients: A
single-center retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I believe the authors' responses have addressed most of my concerns (except for a few issues
that are unavoidable due to the study design and the problems it aims to solve).
However, the quality of the figures remains concerning, particularly regarding pixel resolution,
font issues, and inconsistencies in font capitalization. As a high-level journal, such figure quality
should not be acceptable. I strongly recommend that the authors make the necessary adjustments.
Once these issues are resolved, I suggest that this article be accepted for publication in BMC
Gastroenterology.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinicopathological features of early-onset colorectal cancer in Japanese patients: A
single-center retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I believe the authors' responses have addressed most of my concerns (except for a few issues
that are unavoidable due to the study design and the problems it aims to solve).
However, the quality of the figures remains concerning, particularly regarding pixel resolution,
font issues, and inconsistencies in font capitalization. As a high-level journal, such figure quality
should not be acceptable. I strongly recommend that the authors make the necessary adjustments.
Once these issues are resolved, I suggest that this article be accepted for publication in BMC
Gastroenterology.
assistant