Title: Analysis of the distribution characteristics of pathogenic bacteria in the wound tissue of
patients with perianal abscess combined with infection and the influencing factors of wound
healing
Version: 2 Date: 28 Dec 2024
Reviewer:  Yalda Malekzadegan
Reviewer's report:
In this manuscript the authors present data on the analysis of the distribution characteristics of
pathogenic bacteria in the wound tissue of patients with perianal abscess combined with infection
and the influencing factors of wound healing. However, there are several scientific writing,
methodological, analysis and interpretation problems with the study which must be corrected,
(see specific points below).
1. Some sentence is very long. It is better to write them shorter.
2. In introduction, explain more about the types of microbes isolated from perianal abscess
combined with infection.
3. The type of study not mentioned.
4. For bacterial detection, the author must provide references or explain the method.
5. How were the samples protected from contamination during transport?
6. Please keep correct scientific writing for bacterial and fungal name in entire manuscript, e.g.
Klebsiella pneumonia must be corrected as Klebsiella pneumoniae; gram-negative bacilli must
be corrected as Gram-negative bacilli and so on…
7. The title mentions isolated bacteria, but the table also lists the names of isolated fungi. If
fungus is also considered, the title should be changed to microbe and title of table 1 and figue1
must be changed.
8. Please enter references correct with endnote format.
Title: Analysis of the distribution characteristics of pathogenic bacteria in the wound tissue of
patients with perianal abscess combined with infection and the influencing factors of wound
healing
Version: 2 Date: 28 Dec 2024
Reviewer:  Yalda Malekzadegan
Reviewer's report:
In this manuscript the authors present data on the analysis of the distribution characteristics of
pathogenic bacteria in the wound tissue of patients with perianal abscess combined with infection
and the influencing factors of wound healing. However, there are several scientific writing,
methodological, analysis and interpretation problems with the study which must be corrected,
(see specific points below).
1. Some sentence is very long. It is better to write them shorter.
2. In introduction, explain more about the types of microbes isolated from perianal abscess
combined with infection.
3. The type of study not mentioned.
4. For bacterial detection, the author must provide references or explain the method.
5. How were the samples protected from contamination during transport?
6. Please keep correct scientific writing for bacterial and fungal name in entire manuscript, e.g.
Klebsiella pneumonia must be corrected as Klebsiella pneumoniae; gram-negative bacilli must
be corrected as Gram-negative bacilli and so on…
7. The title mentions isolated bacteria, but the table also lists the names of isolated fungi. If
fungus is also considered, the title should be changed to microbe and title of table 1 and figue1
must be changed.
8. Please enter references correct with endnote format.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Analysis of the distribution characteristics of pathogenic bacteria in the wound tissue of
patients with perianal abscess combined with infection and the influencing factors of wound
healing
Version: 2 Date: 28 Dec 2024
Reviewer:  Yalda Malekzadegan
Reviewer's report:
In this manuscript the authors present data on the analysis of the distribution characteristics of
pathogenic bacteria in the wound tissue of patients with perianal abscess combined with infection
and the influencing factors of wound healing. However, there are several scientific writing,
methodological, analysis and interpretation problems with the study which must be corrected,
(see specific points below).
1. Some sentence is very long. It is better to write them shorter.
2. In introduction, explain more about the types of microbes isolated from perianal abscess
combined with infection.
3. The type of study not mentioned.
4. For bacterial detection, the author must provide references or explain the method.
5. How were the samples protected from contamination during transport?
6. Please keep correct scientific writing for bacterial and fungal name in entire manuscript, e.g.
Klebsiella pneumonia must be corrected as Klebsiella pneumoniae; gram-negative bacilli must
be corrected as Gram-negative bacilli and so on…
7. The title mentions isolated bacteria, but the table also lists the names of isolated fungi. If
fungus is also considered, the title should be changed to microbe and title of table 1 and figue1
must be changed.
8. Please enter references correct with endnote format.
assistant