Title: Whether the Golgi Protein 73 Could Be A Diagnostic Serological Marker in
Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Meta Analysis
Version: 4 Date: 02 Jan 2023
Reviewer:  Fabio Melandro
Reviewer's report:
I read the paper of Zhang et al. with great interest. in the review and meta analysis, the authors
analyzed article the diagnostic role of Golgi protein 73 marker in the field of hepatocellular
carcinoma and his value for differential diagnosis between HCC and chirrosis
The paper is interesting and well written; the quality of statistical analysis is satisfactory and the
relevant literature is adequately covered in the analysis.
Discussion is very complete.
There are only few suggestions to the authors in order to improve the strength of their study:
1. Could You improve the flow diagram of the research with PRISMA layout and respect
PRISMA guidelines?
2. In the flow diagram could You define the reason for not relevance of the articles (eg. animal
study, letter to editor...)
Thanks
Title: Whether the Golgi Protein 73 Could Be A Diagnostic Serological Marker in
Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Meta Analysis
Version: 4 Date: 02 Jan 2023
Reviewer:  Fabio Melandro
Reviewer's report:
I read the paper of Zhang et al. with great interest. in the review and meta analysis, the authors
analyzed article the diagnostic role of Golgi protein 73 marker in the field of hepatocellular
carcinoma and his value for differential diagnosis between HCC and chirrosis
The paper is interesting and well written; the quality of statistical analysis is satisfactory and the
relevant literature is adequately covered in the analysis.
Discussion is very complete.
There are only few suggestions to the authors in order to improve the strength of their study:
1. Could You improve the flow diagram of the research with PRISMA layout and respect
PRISMA guidelines?
2. In the flow diagram could You define the reason for not relevance of the articles (eg. animal
study, letter to editor...)
Thanks
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Whether the Golgi Protein 73 Could Be A Diagnostic Serological Marker in
Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Meta Analysis
Version: 4 Date: 02 Jan 2023
Reviewer:  Fabio Melandro
Reviewer's report:
I read the paper of Zhang et al. with great interest. in the review and meta analysis, the authors
analyzed article the diagnostic role of Golgi protein 73 marker in the field of hepatocellular
carcinoma and his value for differential diagnosis between HCC and chirrosis
The paper is interesting and well written; the quality of statistical analysis is satisfactory and the
relevant literature is adequately covered in the analysis.
Discussion is very complete.
There are only few suggestions to the authors in order to improve the strength of their study:
1. Could You improve the flow diagram of the research with PRISMA layout and respect
PRISMA guidelines?
2. In the flow diagram could You define the reason for not relevance of the articles (eg. animal
study, letter to editor...)
Thanks
assistant