Title: Predictive Model for Identification of Gangrenous or Perforated Appendicitis in Adults:
A Multicenter Retrospective Study
Version: 6 Date: 02 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Florin Iordache
Reviewer's report:
I welcome the prompt response from the authors addressing most of the issues I have pointed
out before. Still, I have not understood why patients aged over 65 years old were excluded as
they tend to have some additional risks for complicated appendicitis (please clarify).
And a minor issue: I think the present tense would be preferable in the method chapter because
the study was already performed.
Title: Predictive Model for Identification of Gangrenous or Perforated Appendicitis in Adults:
A Multicenter Retrospective Study
Version: 6 Date: 02 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Florin Iordache
Reviewer's report:
I welcome the prompt response from the authors addressing most of the issues I have pointed
out before. Still, I have not understood why patients aged over 65 years old were excluded as
they tend to have some additional risks for complicated appendicitis (please clarify).
And a minor issue: I think the present tense would be preferable in the method chapter because
the study was already performed.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Predictive Model for Identification of Gangrenous or Perforated Appendicitis in Adults:
A Multicenter Retrospective Study
Version: 6 Date: 02 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Florin Iordache
Reviewer's report:
I welcome the prompt response from the authors addressing most of the issues I have pointed
out before. Still, I have not understood why patients aged over 65 years old were excluded as
they tend to have some additional risks for complicated appendicitis (please clarify).
And a minor issue: I think the present tense would be preferable in the method chapter because
the study was already performed.
assistant