Title: Clinical study on the necessity and feasibility of routine MRCP in patients with
cholecystolithiasis before LC
Version: 4 Date: 16 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
When reviewing the authors’ responses and the latest version of the manuscript, I evaluated the
accuracy and validity of the manuscript. The authors addressed my comments and substantially
improved the quality of the paper.
Concerning the question point 7  the response is not completely satisfactory. I think that your
comment should be added in the discussion  with the suggested references, so I suggest the
authors to write that in few lines in order to underline the importance that multimodal imaging
technology such as intraoperative fluorescent cholangiography combined with pre-op MRCP
examination are  very useful for better definition of biliary anatomy in such contexts. It is very
important for readers to better understand this issue, by improving the quality of your paper.
Title: Clinical study on the necessity and feasibility of routine MRCP in patients with
cholecystolithiasis before LC
Version: 4 Date: 16 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
When reviewing the authors’ responses and the latest version of the manuscript, I evaluated the
accuracy and validity of the manuscript. The authors addressed my comments and substantially
improved the quality of the paper.
Concerning the question point 7  the response is not completely satisfactory. I think that your
comment should be added in the discussion  with the suggested references, so I suggest the
authors to write that in few lines in order to underline the importance that multimodal imaging
technology such as intraoperative fluorescent cholangiography combined with pre-op MRCP
examination are  very useful for better definition of biliary anatomy in such contexts. It is very
important for readers to better understand this issue, by improving the quality of your paper.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinical study on the necessity and feasibility of routine MRCP in patients with
cholecystolithiasis before LC
Version: 4 Date: 16 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
When reviewing the authors’ responses and the latest version of the manuscript, I evaluated the
accuracy and validity of the manuscript. The authors addressed my comments and substantially
improved the quality of the paper.
Concerning the question point 7  the response is not completely satisfactory. I think that your
comment should be added in the discussion  with the suggested references, so I suggest the
authors to write that in few lines in order to underline the importance that multimodal imaging
technology such as intraoperative fluorescent cholangiography combined with pre-op MRCP
examination are  very useful for better definition of biliary anatomy in such contexts. It is very
important for readers to better understand this issue, by improving the quality of your paper.
assistant