Title: KIF3C inhibits the progression and proliferation of colorectal cancer
Version: 4 Date: 25 Jul 2024
Reviewer:  Kumar S. Bishnupuri
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is primarily focused on defining the role of KIF3C in colorectal carcinogenesis.
Although the manuscript includes some interesting data, it needs extensive edits and rewriting
even to follow the results. Even the title of the manuscript 'KIF3C Promotes Human Colorectal
Cancer Cell Proliferation by Inhibiting Dependant (???) Cell Cycle Progression' appears
to be confusing. Abstract: Methods - what is the meaning of meaning of transcription of
KIF3C, why results are included, i.e. we showed that KIF3C impacts..............pathway; we
demonstrated .....................with tumor prognosis, Results: what is the meaning of 'expression of
replicative, migratory and invasive capabilities'. Similar issues exist throughout the manuscript.
Overall, the manuscript needs extensive edits and rewriting to analyze the results in a proper way.
Title: KIF3C inhibits the progression and proliferation of colorectal cancer
Version: 4 Date: 25 Jul 2024
Reviewer:  Kumar S. Bishnupuri
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is primarily focused on defining the role of KIF3C in colorectal carcinogenesis.
Although the manuscript includes some interesting data, it needs extensive edits and rewriting
even to follow the results. Even the title of the manuscript 'KIF3C Promotes Human Colorectal
Cancer Cell Proliferation by Inhibiting Dependant (???) Cell Cycle Progression' appears
to be confusing. Abstract: Methods - what is the meaning of meaning of transcription of
KIF3C, why results are included, i.e. we showed that KIF3C impacts..............pathway; we
demonstrated .....................with tumor prognosis, Results: what is the meaning of 'expression of
replicative, migratory and invasive capabilities'. Similar issues exist throughout the manuscript.
Overall, the manuscript needs extensive edits and rewriting to analyze the results in a proper way.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: KIF3C inhibits the progression and proliferation of colorectal cancer
Version: 4 Date: 25 Jul 2024
Reviewer:  Kumar S. Bishnupuri
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is primarily focused on defining the role of KIF3C in colorectal carcinogenesis.
Although the manuscript includes some interesting data, it needs extensive edits and rewriting
even to follow the results. Even the title of the manuscript 'KIF3C Promotes Human Colorectal
Cancer Cell Proliferation by Inhibiting Dependant (???) Cell Cycle Progression' appears
to be confusing. Abstract: Methods - what is the meaning of meaning of transcription of
KIF3C, why results are included, i.e. we showed that KIF3C impacts..............pathway; we
demonstrated .....................with tumor prognosis, Results: what is the meaning of 'expression of
replicative, migratory and invasive capabilities'. Similar issues exist throughout the manuscript.
Overall, the manuscript needs extensive edits and rewriting to analyze the results in a proper way.
assistant