Title: Clinical study on conversion therapy of hepatocellular carcinoma - Summary and
comparison of clinical data from a single center of  consecutive four years
Version: 3 Date: 11 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
(A)An overview of the manuscript
This preliminary study has been undertaken to investigate the surgical safety and survival
outcomes of patients with initial unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma (uHCC) after conversion
therapy.
It is observed that a small percentage (1.81%) of uHCC patients are likely to be converted to
radical resection. It is suggested that a small percentage (1.81%) of uHCC patients are likely
to be converted to radical
(B) Introduction and discussion:
All relevant previously published studies have been cited
The work's aims, significance, and novelty are clearly outlined in the manuscript.
(C) Materials and methods:
The methods and statistical analyses are appropriate.
The manuscript complies with relevant national or international ethics guidelines.
(D) Results
The data presented is convincing regarding the reliability and validity of the results and figures.
The authors present the relevant controls.
The data support all the conclusions made by the authors.
(E) The level of the English
The manuscript does not require further revisions by a language editing company or a native
English speaker; however, a minor revision is required.
Title: Clinical study on conversion therapy of hepatocellular carcinoma - Summary and
comparison of clinical data from a single center of  consecutive four years
Version: 3 Date: 11 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
(A)An overview of the manuscript
This preliminary study has been undertaken to investigate the surgical safety and survival
outcomes of patients with initial unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma (uHCC) after conversion
therapy.
It is observed that a small percentage (1.81%) of uHCC patients are likely to be converted to
radical resection. It is suggested that a small percentage (1.81%) of uHCC patients are likely
to be converted to radical
(B) Introduction and discussion:
All relevant previously published studies have been cited
The work's aims, significance, and novelty are clearly outlined in the manuscript.
(C) Materials and methods:
The methods and statistical analyses are appropriate.
The manuscript complies with relevant national or international ethics guidelines.
(D) Results
The data presented is convincing regarding the reliability and validity of the results and figures.
The authors present the relevant controls.
The data support all the conclusions made by the authors.
(E) The level of the English
The manuscript does not require further revisions by a language editing company or a native
English speaker; however, a minor revision is required.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinical study on conversion therapy of hepatocellular carcinoma - Summary and
comparison of clinical data from a single center of  consecutive four years
Version: 3 Date: 11 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
(A)An overview of the manuscript
This preliminary study has been undertaken to investigate the surgical safety and survival
outcomes of patients with initial unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma (uHCC) after conversion
therapy.
It is observed that a small percentage (1.81%) of uHCC patients are likely to be converted to
radical resection. It is suggested that a small percentage (1.81%) of uHCC patients are likely
to be converted to radical
(B) Introduction and discussion:
All relevant previously published studies have been cited
The work's aims, significance, and novelty are clearly outlined in the manuscript.
(C) Materials and methods:
The methods and statistical analyses are appropriate.
The manuscript complies with relevant national or international ethics guidelines.
(D) Results
The data presented is convincing regarding the reliability and validity of the results and figures.
The authors present the relevant controls.
The data support all the conclusions made by the authors.
(E) The level of the English
The manuscript does not require further revisions by a language editing company or a native
English speaker; however, a minor revision is required.
assistant