Title: Emphasis on the Clinical relationship between Alpha-Fetoprotein and Hepatoid
adenocarcinoma of the stomach: a retrospective study
Version: 2 Date: 27 Dec 2022
Reviewer's report:
Thank you very much.
There are few points to revisite:
1. In my opinion the paper is not including  pathology perspective of these rare entity. With this
title,  I have expected to see at least the pathologic criteria  for diagnosis (which is an conflicting
issue),  diagnostic approach / diagnostic pitfalls for pathologic diagnosis. The tittle should be
revisited to turely  indicate that the article addresses clinical course and prognostic data.
2. Table 1:'pTNM (IV)' is written.IV should be omitted.
Surgical resection ( the last line) should be aligned.
3. line 112.... , 'invaded the plasma membrane, or invaded adjacent tissue or organs. ' Did you
mean peritoneal membrane? It would be better to say serosa. (also in the lines 133-134 and some
others in the  discussion part )
4. Table 2: size (cm)
Thank you
Title: Emphasis on the Clinical relationship between Alpha-Fetoprotein and Hepatoid
adenocarcinoma of the stomach: a retrospective study
Version: 2 Date: 27 Dec 2022
Reviewer's report:
Thank you very much.
There are few points to revisite:
1. In my opinion the paper is not including  pathology perspective of these rare entity. With this
title,  I have expected to see at least the pathologic criteria  for diagnosis (which is an conflicting
issue),  diagnostic approach / diagnostic pitfalls for pathologic diagnosis. The tittle should be
revisited to turely  indicate that the article addresses clinical course and prognostic data.
2. Table 1:'pTNM (IV)' is written.IV should be omitted.
Surgical resection ( the last line) should be aligned.
3. line 112.... , 'invaded the plasma membrane, or invaded adjacent tissue or organs. ' Did you
mean peritoneal membrane? It would be better to say serosa. (also in the lines 133-134 and some
others in the  discussion part )
4. Table 2: size (cm)
Thank you
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Emphasis on the Clinical relationship between Alpha-Fetoprotein and Hepatoid
adenocarcinoma of the stomach: a retrospective study
Version: 2 Date: 27 Dec 2022
Reviewer's report:
Thank you very much.
There are few points to revisite:
1. In my opinion the paper is not including  pathology perspective of these rare entity. With this
title,  I have expected to see at least the pathologic criteria  for diagnosis (which is an conflicting
issue),  diagnostic approach / diagnostic pitfalls for pathologic diagnosis. The tittle should be
revisited to turely  indicate that the article addresses clinical course and prognostic data.
2. Table 1:'pTNM (IV)' is written.IV should be omitted.
Surgical resection ( the last line) should be aligned.
3. line 112.... , 'invaded the plasma membrane, or invaded adjacent tissue or organs. ' Did you
mean peritoneal membrane? It would be better to say serosa. (also in the lines 133-134 and some
others in the  discussion part )
4. Table 2: size (cm)
Thank you
assistant