Title: Value of CT sinography and analysis of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis for abdominal
wall sinus
Version: 1 Date: 22 Mar 2022
Reviewer:  Giovanni Foti
Reviewer's report:
this is a nice paper describing CT findings of sinus and fistulas
ABSTRACT
in methods give period of study and number and eperience of readers involved. Also briefly
describe the imaging findings used for CT diagnosis.
in results, give confidence interval for se and specificity
INTRODUCTION
ok
METHODS
did the authors used diluted contrast material or without any dilution?
create a diagram with patietns included, with inclusion and exclusion criteria
inter-observer agreement between readers could be useful
also give years of experience of each reader
DISCUSSION
I suggest to discuss the possibility to perform a dedicated additional study for difficult case;
for example a CT urogrphy, distending the urinary bladder with contrast material from inside,
could be used to rule out the fistula.
TABLES
I would include the 95% CI of accuracy values if possible
FIGURES
are nice; I would crop on main finginds when possible
Title: Value of CT sinography and analysis of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis for abdominal
wall sinus
Version: 1 Date: 22 Mar 2022
Reviewer:  Giovanni Foti
Reviewer's report:
this is a nice paper describing CT findings of sinus and fistulas
ABSTRACT
in methods give period of study and number and eperience of readers involved. Also briefly
describe the imaging findings used for CT diagnosis.
in results, give confidence interval for se and specificity
INTRODUCTION
ok
METHODS
did the authors used diluted contrast material or without any dilution?
create a diagram with patietns included, with inclusion and exclusion criteria
inter-observer agreement between readers could be useful
also give years of experience of each reader
DISCUSSION
I suggest to discuss the possibility to perform a dedicated additional study for difficult case;
for example a CT urogrphy, distending the urinary bladder with contrast material from inside,
could be used to rule out the fistula.
TABLES
I would include the 95% CI of accuracy values if possible
FIGURES
are nice; I would crop on main finginds when possible
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Value of CT sinography and analysis of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis for abdominal
wall sinus
Version: 1 Date: 22 Mar 2022
Reviewer:  Giovanni Foti
Reviewer's report:
this is a nice paper describing CT findings of sinus and fistulas
ABSTRACT
in methods give period of study and number and eperience of readers involved. Also briefly
describe the imaging findings used for CT diagnosis.
in results, give confidence interval for se and specificity
INTRODUCTION
ok
METHODS
did the authors used diluted contrast material or without any dilution?
create a diagram with patietns included, with inclusion and exclusion criteria
inter-observer agreement between readers could be useful
also give years of experience of each reader
DISCUSSION
I suggest to discuss the possibility to perform a dedicated additional study for difficult case;
for example a CT urogrphy, distending the urinary bladder with contrast material from inside,
could be used to rule out the fistula.
TABLES
I would include the 95% CI of accuracy values if possible
FIGURES
are nice; I would crop on main finginds when possible
assistant