Title: Clinical analysis of acute pancreatitis after renal transplantation: a single-center
retrospective observational study
Version: 4 Date: 20 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author;
First of all, thank you for this intriguing study.
1- The study should be conducted with more patients.
2- How other etiologies are excluded in transplant patients with drug-related pancreatitis should
be mentioned in the article.
3- Which patients developed necrotizing pancreatitis should be specified, and the effectiveness
of the treatment should be evaluated by classifying patients according to the severity of
pancreatitis.
4- I recommend that the patients included in the study should be classified etiologically and
differences according to etiology be determined after treatment. For this reason, when the
etiological reasons are evaluated, I think that the number of patients is not sufficient. For this
reason, I recommend that the study be expanded by increasing the number of patients.
Title: Clinical analysis of acute pancreatitis after renal transplantation: a single-center
retrospective observational study
Version: 4 Date: 20 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author;
First of all, thank you for this intriguing study.
1- The study should be conducted with more patients.
2- How other etiologies are excluded in transplant patients with drug-related pancreatitis should
be mentioned in the article.
3- Which patients developed necrotizing pancreatitis should be specified, and the effectiveness
of the treatment should be evaluated by classifying patients according to the severity of
pancreatitis.
4- I recommend that the patients included in the study should be classified etiologically and
differences according to etiology be determined after treatment. For this reason, when the
etiological reasons are evaluated, I think that the number of patients is not sufficient. For this
reason, I recommend that the study be expanded by increasing the number of patients.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinical analysis of acute pancreatitis after renal transplantation: a single-center
retrospective observational study
Version: 4 Date: 20 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author;
First of all, thank you for this intriguing study.
1- The study should be conducted with more patients.
2- How other etiologies are excluded in transplant patients with drug-related pancreatitis should
be mentioned in the article.
3- Which patients developed necrotizing pancreatitis should be specified, and the effectiveness
of the treatment should be evaluated by classifying patients according to the severity of
pancreatitis.
4- I recommend that the patients included in the study should be classified etiologically and
differences according to etiology be determined after treatment. For this reason, when the
etiological reasons are evaluated, I think that the number of patients is not sufficient. For this
reason, I recommend that the study be expanded by increasing the number of patients.
assistant