Title: Ascites Complications Risk Factors of Decompensated Cirrhosis Patients: Logistic
Regression and Prediction Model
Version: 0 Date: 09 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
The study presents an interesting predictive model for ascites development.
Although cohort size is small, the results seem quite usefull.
There are some issues that need to be solved though:
1. Line 97: The state regarding MAIT cells needs better explanation. It seems irrelevant
otherwise.
2. Line 179: Child-Pugh classification is 5-6 class A , 7-9 class B , and 10-15 class C.
3. Line 189: There are revisions of Declaration of Helsinki, last one on 2024.
4. Line 221: The correct Child-Pugh classification needs to be presented.
5. In general Introduction and Discussion have a lot in common. The text needs revision.
6. Line 443: Reference 21 & 22 are the same.
7. Figure 4 nomogram needs better legend that explains what it shows.
Title: Ascites Complications Risk Factors of Decompensated Cirrhosis Patients: Logistic
Regression and Prediction Model
Version: 0 Date: 09 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
The study presents an interesting predictive model for ascites development.
Although cohort size is small, the results seem quite usefull.
There are some issues that need to be solved though:
1. Line 97: The state regarding MAIT cells needs better explanation. It seems irrelevant
otherwise.
2. Line 179: Child-Pugh classification is 5-6 class A , 7-9 class B , and 10-15 class C.
3. Line 189: There are revisions of Declaration of Helsinki, last one on 2024.
4. Line 221: The correct Child-Pugh classification needs to be presented.
5. In general Introduction and Discussion have a lot in common. The text needs revision.
6. Line 443: Reference 21 & 22 are the same.
7. Figure 4 nomogram needs better legend that explains what it shows.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Ascites Complications Risk Factors of Decompensated Cirrhosis Patients: Logistic
Regression and Prediction Model
Version: 0 Date: 09 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
The study presents an interesting predictive model for ascites development.
Although cohort size is small, the results seem quite usefull.
There are some issues that need to be solved though:
1. Line 97: The state regarding MAIT cells needs better explanation. It seems irrelevant
otherwise.
2. Line 179: Child-Pugh classification is 5-6 class A , 7-9 class B , and 10-15 class C.
3. Line 189: There are revisions of Declaration of Helsinki, last one on 2024.
4. Line 221: The correct Child-Pugh classification needs to be presented.
5. In general Introduction and Discussion have a lot in common. The text needs revision.
6. Line 443: Reference 21 & 22 are the same.
7. Figure 4 nomogram needs better legend that explains what it shows.
assistant