Title: Prognostic Factors and Adjuvant Chemotherapy Efficacy in Stage I Gastric Cancer
Patients: A Retrospective Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 02 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
As a retrospective single-center study, some limitations of the article are inevitable. For example,
the lack of a standardized adjuvant chemotherapy (AC) protocol: The non-uniformity of the AC
regimens and the fact that the decision to receive AC is left to the patients increases the difficulty
in assessing the effectiveness of AC. I hope the authors can fully explain these limitations in the
discussion. This article provides important insights into the prognostic factors and the efficacy of
adjuvant chemotherapy in stage I gastric cancer patients, but due to the limitations in its design
and implementation, further validation of its findings is needed through prospective, multicenter
studies.
Title: Prognostic Factors and Adjuvant Chemotherapy Efficacy in Stage I Gastric Cancer
Patients: A Retrospective Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 02 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
As a retrospective single-center study, some limitations of the article are inevitable. For example,
the lack of a standardized adjuvant chemotherapy (AC) protocol: The non-uniformity of the AC
regimens and the fact that the decision to receive AC is left to the patients increases the difficulty
in assessing the effectiveness of AC. I hope the authors can fully explain these limitations in the
discussion. This article provides important insights into the prognostic factors and the efficacy of
adjuvant chemotherapy in stage I gastric cancer patients, but due to the limitations in its design
and implementation, further validation of its findings is needed through prospective, multicenter
studies.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Prognostic Factors and Adjuvant Chemotherapy Efficacy in Stage I Gastric Cancer
Patients: A Retrospective Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 02 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
As a retrospective single-center study, some limitations of the article are inevitable. For example,
the lack of a standardized adjuvant chemotherapy (AC) protocol: The non-uniformity of the AC
regimens and the fact that the decision to receive AC is left to the patients increases the difficulty
in assessing the effectiveness of AC. I hope the authors can fully explain these limitations in the
discussion. This article provides important insights into the prognostic factors and the efficacy of
adjuvant chemotherapy in stage I gastric cancer patients, but due to the limitations in its design
and implementation, further validation of its findings is needed through prospective, multicenter
studies.
assistant