Title: The association between plant-based diet indices and risk of mortality in patients with
cirrhosis: a cohort Study
Version: 3 Date: 21 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors provided explanations for the reviewers' comments in their response letter and
made corresponding revisions. However, several important issues were only addressed in
explanations and not reflected in the revised manuscript. For example, in comment 3, regarding
the determination of death outcomes, the authors stated in their response letter, "The cause
of death of the patients was determined based on their death certificate. In addition to the
death certificate, the cause and date of death were also recorded by searching the name of the
deceased in the registry system." However, the manuscript still states, "Follow-up questionnaires
regarding deaths or medical events were completed by telephone."
Title: The association between plant-based diet indices and risk of mortality in patients with
cirrhosis: a cohort Study
Version: 3 Date: 21 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors provided explanations for the reviewers' comments in their response letter and
made corresponding revisions. However, several important issues were only addressed in
explanations and not reflected in the revised manuscript. For example, in comment 3, regarding
the determination of death outcomes, the authors stated in their response letter, "The cause
of death of the patients was determined based on their death certificate. In addition to the
death certificate, the cause and date of death were also recorded by searching the name of the
deceased in the registry system." However, the manuscript still states, "Follow-up questionnaires
regarding deaths or medical events were completed by telephone."
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The association between plant-based diet indices and risk of mortality in patients with
cirrhosis: a cohort Study
Version: 3 Date: 21 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors provided explanations for the reviewers' comments in their response letter and
made corresponding revisions. However, several important issues were only addressed in
explanations and not reflected in the revised manuscript. For example, in comment 3, regarding
the determination of death outcomes, the authors stated in their response letter, "The cause
of death of the patients was determined based on their death certificate. In addition to the
death certificate, the cause and date of death were also recorded by searching the name of the
deceased in the registry system." However, the manuscript still states, "Follow-up questionnaires
regarding deaths or medical events were completed by telephone."
assistant