Title: Milligan–Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with rubber band ligation and
polidocanol foam sclerotherapy for the management of grade III/IV hemorrhoids: A
retrospective study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Apr 2025
Reviewer:  #. Çolak
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript has positive and negative aspects. The positive aspect includes the comparison
of two surgical methods used in the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease, which affects the majority
of the world's population. In this respect, it provides useful information in surgical practice. The
negative aspect is that the study is retrospective and similar studies have been conducted on
hemorrhoids.
There are publications in the literature on combined surgical treatment of hemorrhoids. The
feature that makes this study stand out is the use of sclerosing agents that minimize the
complications of band ligation. This situation makes this study slightly different from others.
In the world of science, the contribution of very small nuances to practical life is very valuable.
Therefore, it deserves this article.
Similar studies have been published in your journal before, so it is appropriate for the editors
to decide on your publication policy.
Title: Milligan–Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with rubber band ligation and
polidocanol foam sclerotherapy for the management of grade III/IV hemorrhoids: A
retrospective study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Apr 2025
Reviewer:  #. Çolak
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript has positive and negative aspects. The positive aspect includes the comparison
of two surgical methods used in the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease, which affects the majority
of the world's population. In this respect, it provides useful information in surgical practice. The
negative aspect is that the study is retrospective and similar studies have been conducted on
hemorrhoids.
There are publications in the literature on combined surgical treatment of hemorrhoids. The
feature that makes this study stand out is the use of sclerosing agents that minimize the
complications of band ligation. This situation makes this study slightly different from others.
In the world of science, the contribution of very small nuances to practical life is very valuable.
Therefore, it deserves this article.
Similar studies have been published in your journal before, so it is appropriate for the editors
to decide on your publication policy.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Milligan–Morgan hemorrhoidectomy combined with rubber band ligation and
polidocanol foam sclerotherapy for the management of grade III/IV hemorrhoids: A
retrospective study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Apr 2025
Reviewer:  #. Çolak
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript has positive and negative aspects. The positive aspect includes the comparison
of two surgical methods used in the treatment of hemorrhoidal disease, which affects the majority
of the world's population. In this respect, it provides useful information in surgical practice. The
negative aspect is that the study is retrospective and similar studies have been conducted on
hemorrhoids.
There are publications in the literature on combined surgical treatment of hemorrhoids. The
feature that makes this study stand out is the use of sclerosing agents that minimize the
complications of band ligation. This situation makes this study slightly different from others.
In the world of science, the contribution of very small nuances to practical life is very valuable.
Therefore, it deserves this article.
Similar studies have been published in your journal before, so it is appropriate for the editors
to decide on your publication policy.
assistant