Title: Gallbladder-preserving polypectomy for gallbladder polyp by embryonic-natural orifice
transumbilical endoscopic surgery with a gastric endoscopy
Version: 2 Date: 02 Nov 2021
Reviewer's report:
I believe this work shouldn´t be published.
1. With 12 cases you can´t say its a safe procedure. Complications after lap chole are very rare.
Just 1 bile leak from the gallbladder will render the procedure of NOTES risky. You overstate
the complications of cholecystectomy...colon cancer??? In the long term patients don´t even
remember the date of their cholecystectomy. There is no need for this procedure.
2. Polyps less than 5 mm should´t even be operated, and thos of 5-10 mm is very controversial.
Why are you offering a risky procedure to these patients? Are they properly informed about
their diagnosis?
3. Length of stay of 5 or more days after the procedure. Lap chole in these patients is ambulatory.
Why so many days?
Title: Gallbladder-preserving polypectomy for gallbladder polyp by embryonic-natural orifice
transumbilical endoscopic surgery with a gastric endoscopy
Version: 2 Date: 02 Nov 2021
Reviewer's report:
I believe this work shouldn´t be published.
1. With 12 cases you can´t say its a safe procedure. Complications after lap chole are very rare.
Just 1 bile leak from the gallbladder will render the procedure of NOTES risky. You overstate
the complications of cholecystectomy...colon cancer??? In the long term patients don´t even
remember the date of their cholecystectomy. There is no need for this procedure.
2. Polyps less than 5 mm should´t even be operated, and thos of 5-10 mm is very controversial.
Why are you offering a risky procedure to these patients? Are they properly informed about
their diagnosis?
3. Length of stay of 5 or more days after the procedure. Lap chole in these patients is ambulatory.
Why so many days?
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Gallbladder-preserving polypectomy for gallbladder polyp by embryonic-natural orifice
transumbilical endoscopic surgery with a gastric endoscopy
Version: 2 Date: 02 Nov 2021
Reviewer's report:
I believe this work shouldn´t be published.
1. With 12 cases you can´t say its a safe procedure. Complications after lap chole are very rare.
Just 1 bile leak from the gallbladder will render the procedure of NOTES risky. You overstate
the complications of cholecystectomy...colon cancer??? In the long term patients don´t even
remember the date of their cholecystectomy. There is no need for this procedure.
2. Polyps less than 5 mm should´t even be operated, and thos of 5-10 mm is very controversial.
Why are you offering a risky procedure to these patients? Are they properly informed about
their diagnosis?
3. Length of stay of 5 or more days after the procedure. Lap chole in these patients is ambulatory.
Why so many days?
assistant