Title: Dynamic Variations in Peripheral Blood Indices and Their Association with Efficacy
and Adverse Reactions of PD-1 Inhibitor Combined Chemotherapy in Patients with Advanced
Gastric Cancer
Version: 6 Date: 27 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
Based on the revised version, the authors have made significant revisions that address most of
the major concerns raised previously. The key improvements are:
Improved transparency: The addition of the CONSORT flow diagram is excellent.
Toned-down conclusions: The authors are now appropriately cautious in their interpretations.
Better figure presentation: The Kaplan-Meier curves are significantly improved.
Strengthened discussion: The discussion is more thorough and critically engages with the
existing literature.
Complete ethics statement: The ethics statement is now comprehensive.
I recommend accepting the manuscript.
Title: Dynamic Variations in Peripheral Blood Indices and Their Association with Efficacy
and Adverse Reactions of PD-1 Inhibitor Combined Chemotherapy in Patients with Advanced
Gastric Cancer
Version: 6 Date: 27 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
Based on the revised version, the authors have made significant revisions that address most of
the major concerns raised previously. The key improvements are:
Improved transparency: The addition of the CONSORT flow diagram is excellent.
Toned-down conclusions: The authors are now appropriately cautious in their interpretations.
Better figure presentation: The Kaplan-Meier curves are significantly improved.
Strengthened discussion: The discussion is more thorough and critically engages with the
existing literature.
Complete ethics statement: The ethics statement is now comprehensive.
I recommend accepting the manuscript.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Dynamic Variations in Peripheral Blood Indices and Their Association with Efficacy
and Adverse Reactions of PD-1 Inhibitor Combined Chemotherapy in Patients with Advanced
Gastric Cancer
Version: 6 Date: 27 Mar 2025
Reviewer's report:
Based on the revised version, the authors have made significant revisions that address most of
the major concerns raised previously. The key improvements are:
Improved transparency: The addition of the CONSORT flow diagram is excellent.
Toned-down conclusions: The authors are now appropriately cautious in their interpretations.
Better figure presentation: The Kaplan-Meier curves are significantly improved.
Strengthened discussion: The discussion is more thorough and critically engages with the
existing literature.
Complete ethics statement: The ethics statement is now comprehensive.
I recommend accepting the manuscript.
assistant