Title: The Association Between Oxidative Balance Score with Constipation and Diarrhea in US
Adults: A Cross-sectional Analysis of NHANES 2007–2010
Version: 3 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
CONGRATULATIONS ON TH EGOOD WORK.
SOME MINOR REVISIONS WOULD IMPROVE THE QUALITY.
INTRODUCTION:
1. LINES 50-55 THE DETAILED EPIDEMIOLOGICAL DATA DO NOT ADD IMPORTANT
INFORMATION TO THE READER. THEY COULD BE OMITED OR SHORTENED
2. LINES 57-59 PLEASDE REWRITE TO BE MORE CLEAR
METHODS
3. OBS: IT IS NOT CLEAR HOW YOU CALCULATED OBS FOR ACH PARTICIPANT..
WAS THERE A QUESTIIONNAIRE USED OR ANY LAB TESTS FOR NUTRITIONAL
FACTORS?
4. LINE 145 CONCERNING PHYSICAL ACTIVITY YOU PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED
THAT YOUR DATA DID NOT INCLUDE SPECIFIC INFORMATION FOR ALL
PARTICIPANTS.. YOU COULD INCLUDE AND EXPLAIN THAT IN THAT METHODS
PART.
5.LINES 148-155 REFERENCES FOR THE DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA YOU USED OF
CHRONIC DISEASES ARE NEEDED
RESULTS
6. LINES  178-179 YOU COULD ADD PERCENTAGES IN PARENTHESES AFTER THE
MENTIONED NUMBER
LINES 181-184 ADD P VALUES
GENERAL COMMENT
ENGLISH LANGUAGE COULD BE IMPROVED
Title: The Association Between Oxidative Balance Score with Constipation and Diarrhea in US
Adults: A Cross-sectional Analysis of NHANES 2007–2010
Version: 3 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
CONGRATULATIONS ON TH EGOOD WORK.
SOME MINOR REVISIONS WOULD IMPROVE THE QUALITY.
INTRODUCTION:
1. LINES 50-55 THE DETAILED EPIDEMIOLOGICAL DATA DO NOT ADD IMPORTANT
INFORMATION TO THE READER. THEY COULD BE OMITED OR SHORTENED
2. LINES 57-59 PLEASDE REWRITE TO BE MORE CLEAR
METHODS
3. OBS: IT IS NOT CLEAR HOW YOU CALCULATED OBS FOR ACH PARTICIPANT..
WAS THERE A QUESTIIONNAIRE USED OR ANY LAB TESTS FOR NUTRITIONAL
FACTORS?
4. LINE 145 CONCERNING PHYSICAL ACTIVITY YOU PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED
THAT YOUR DATA DID NOT INCLUDE SPECIFIC INFORMATION FOR ALL
PARTICIPANTS.. YOU COULD INCLUDE AND EXPLAIN THAT IN THAT METHODS
PART.
5.LINES 148-155 REFERENCES FOR THE DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA YOU USED OF
CHRONIC DISEASES ARE NEEDED
RESULTS
6. LINES  178-179 YOU COULD ADD PERCENTAGES IN PARENTHESES AFTER THE
MENTIONED NUMBER
LINES 181-184 ADD P VALUES
GENERAL COMMENT
ENGLISH LANGUAGE COULD BE IMPROVED
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The Association Between Oxidative Balance Score with Constipation and Diarrhea in US
Adults: A Cross-sectional Analysis of NHANES 2007–2010
Version: 3 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
CONGRATULATIONS ON TH EGOOD WORK.
SOME MINOR REVISIONS WOULD IMPROVE THE QUALITY.
INTRODUCTION:
1. LINES 50-55 THE DETAILED EPIDEMIOLOGICAL DATA DO NOT ADD IMPORTANT
INFORMATION TO THE READER. THEY COULD BE OMITED OR SHORTENED
2. LINES 57-59 PLEASDE REWRITE TO BE MORE CLEAR
METHODS
3. OBS: IT IS NOT CLEAR HOW YOU CALCULATED OBS FOR ACH PARTICIPANT..
WAS THERE A QUESTIIONNAIRE USED OR ANY LAB TESTS FOR NUTRITIONAL
FACTORS?
4. LINE 145 CONCERNING PHYSICAL ACTIVITY YOU PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED
THAT YOUR DATA DID NOT INCLUDE SPECIFIC INFORMATION FOR ALL
PARTICIPANTS.. YOU COULD INCLUDE AND EXPLAIN THAT IN THAT METHODS
PART.
5.LINES 148-155 REFERENCES FOR THE DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA YOU USED OF
CHRONIC DISEASES ARE NEEDED
RESULTS
6. LINES  178-179 YOU COULD ADD PERCENTAGES IN PARENTHESES AFTER THE
MENTIONED NUMBER
LINES 181-184 ADD P VALUES
GENERAL COMMENT
ENGLISH LANGUAGE COULD BE IMPROVED
assistant