Title: Alterations of Liver Enzymes and Lipid Profile in Response to Exhaustive Eccentric
Exercise: Vitamin D supplementation trial in Overweight Females with Non-Alcoholic Fatty
Liver Disease
Version: 3 Date: 21 Jun 2022
Reviewer's report:
This study by Rahimpour et al., describes the short-term Vit D supplementation could regulate
the high liver enzymes and lipid profile induced by eccentric exhaustive exercise. In addition,
six-week supplementation of Vit D significantly reduced liver enzymes and lipid profile. Finally,
Vit D supplementation could be recommended to NAFLD patients to reduce liver enzymes
and lipid profile following vigorous activities. I think it still may present an interest for other
researchers. However, there are some questions that need to be addressed.
Background: this part is tedious and hard to follow. These descriptions are occupied too much
spaces; the authors should be written more concisely.
Methods: I suggest that the authors need to indicate the more and clear method which it was
originate from or cited. did you check for normality before using parametrical tests? You have 2
treatment groups: could you please specify in which cases you chose to test them in pairs (t-test)?
Discussion: these descriptions are disorderly. I suggest that the authors need to provide more
references to exhibit the different results in the section.
Title: Alterations of Liver Enzymes and Lipid Profile in Response to Exhaustive Eccentric
Exercise: Vitamin D supplementation trial in Overweight Females with Non-Alcoholic Fatty
Liver Disease
Version: 3 Date: 21 Jun 2022
Reviewer's report:
This study by Rahimpour et al., describes the short-term Vit D supplementation could regulate
the high liver enzymes and lipid profile induced by eccentric exhaustive exercise. In addition,
six-week supplementation of Vit D significantly reduced liver enzymes and lipid profile. Finally,
Vit D supplementation could be recommended to NAFLD patients to reduce liver enzymes
and lipid profile following vigorous activities. I think it still may present an interest for other
researchers. However, there are some questions that need to be addressed.
Background: this part is tedious and hard to follow. These descriptions are occupied too much
spaces; the authors should be written more concisely.
Methods: I suggest that the authors need to indicate the more and clear method which it was
originate from or cited. did you check for normality before using parametrical tests? You have 2
treatment groups: could you please specify in which cases you chose to test them in pairs (t-test)?
Discussion: these descriptions are disorderly. I suggest that the authors need to provide more
references to exhibit the different results in the section.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Alterations of Liver Enzymes and Lipid Profile in Response to Exhaustive Eccentric
Exercise: Vitamin D supplementation trial in Overweight Females with Non-Alcoholic Fatty
Liver Disease
Version: 3 Date: 21 Jun 2022
Reviewer's report:
This study by Rahimpour et al., describes the short-term Vit D supplementation could regulate
the high liver enzymes and lipid profile induced by eccentric exhaustive exercise. In addition,
six-week supplementation of Vit D significantly reduced liver enzymes and lipid profile. Finally,
Vit D supplementation could be recommended to NAFLD patients to reduce liver enzymes
and lipid profile following vigorous activities. I think it still may present an interest for other
researchers. However, there are some questions that need to be addressed.
Background: this part is tedious and hard to follow. These descriptions are occupied too much
spaces; the authors should be written more concisely.
Methods: I suggest that the authors need to indicate the more and clear method which it was
originate from or cited. did you check for normality before using parametrical tests? You have 2
treatment groups: could you please specify in which cases you chose to test them in pairs (t-test)?
Discussion: these descriptions are disorderly. I suggest that the authors need to provide more
references to exhibit the different results in the section.
assistant