Title: Severe Combined Immunodeficiency: Improved survival leading to detection of
underlying liver disease
Version: 9 Date: 10 Apr 2023
Reviewer's report:
The study evaluates a small patient cohort but this is essentially due to the rarity of the pathology
and to the wide spectrum of the ADA deficiency phenotype. In my experience the authors’
conclusions are well detailed and convincing. The quality of this paper has been improved within
the second revision and it represents an interesting evaluation of the non-immunological aspects
of the pathology from which the scientific community could benefit. I my opinion it is suitable
for publication on BMC Gastroenterology
Title: Severe Combined Immunodeficiency: Improved survival leading to detection of
underlying liver disease
Version: 9 Date: 10 Apr 2023
Reviewer's report:
The study evaluates a small patient cohort but this is essentially due to the rarity of the pathology
and to the wide spectrum of the ADA deficiency phenotype. In my experience the authors’
conclusions are well detailed and convincing. The quality of this paper has been improved within
the second revision and it represents an interesting evaluation of the non-immunological aspects
of the pathology from which the scientific community could benefit. I my opinion it is suitable
for publication on BMC Gastroenterology
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Severe Combined Immunodeficiency: Improved survival leading to detection of
underlying liver disease
Version: 9 Date: 10 Apr 2023
Reviewer's report:
The study evaluates a small patient cohort but this is essentially due to the rarity of the pathology
and to the wide spectrum of the ADA deficiency phenotype. In my experience the authors’
conclusions are well detailed and convincing. The quality of this paper has been improved within
the second revision and it represents an interesting evaluation of the non-immunological aspects
of the pathology from which the scientific community could benefit. I my opinion it is suitable
for publication on BMC Gastroenterology
assistant