Title: The Impact of Refined Nursing Management on the Diagnosis of Early Gastric Cancer
under ME-NBI
Version: 3 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
It should be explained why a study that took place in 2021 is presented today Abstract Number
of patients is advisable to be presented in results section Etc is better to be avoided Scale
mentioned in results is better to be presented in methods perhaps by omiting statistical methods
Methods Numerical values belong in the results Indications for H. pylori positive patients should
be defined as well as pepsinogen Was it possible atrophic gastritis? Usually PPIs should be
stopped 3 weeks before gastroscopic while for H2RB a week is adequate Why have authors
selected a 2 week period for both? Organ dysfunction should be defined Which mental disorders
are accepted? Anxiety and dypression should not be excluded Which scale was used to access
anxiety? Was it accessed after the endoscopy and when? Was the score accessing visibility been
validated? In such a case results should be provided   Were biopsies taken during gastroscopy
to define presence of gastritis and H. pylori infection? Was Syndney protocol used for biopsy
taking? Which methods was use to define H. pylori infection apart from UBT? Statistics for
comparison of parameters with more than two variables is better to utilize ANOVA Power of
the study should be moved in statistics
Title: The Impact of Refined Nursing Management on the Diagnosis of Early Gastric Cancer
under ME-NBI
Version: 3 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
It should be explained why a study that took place in 2021 is presented today Abstract Number
of patients is advisable to be presented in results section Etc is better to be avoided Scale
mentioned in results is better to be presented in methods perhaps by omiting statistical methods
Methods Numerical values belong in the results Indications for H. pylori positive patients should
be defined as well as pepsinogen Was it possible atrophic gastritis? Usually PPIs should be
stopped 3 weeks before gastroscopic while for H2RB a week is adequate Why have authors
selected a 2 week period for both? Organ dysfunction should be defined Which mental disorders
are accepted? Anxiety and dypression should not be excluded Which scale was used to access
anxiety? Was it accessed after the endoscopy and when? Was the score accessing visibility been
validated? In such a case results should be provided   Were biopsies taken during gastroscopy
to define presence of gastritis and H. pylori infection? Was Syndney protocol used for biopsy
taking? Which methods was use to define H. pylori infection apart from UBT? Statistics for
comparison of parameters with more than two variables is better to utilize ANOVA Power of
the study should be moved in statistics
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The Impact of Refined Nursing Management on the Diagnosis of Early Gastric Cancer
under ME-NBI
Version: 3 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
It should be explained why a study that took place in 2021 is presented today Abstract Number
of patients is advisable to be presented in results section Etc is better to be avoided Scale
mentioned in results is better to be presented in methods perhaps by omiting statistical methods
Methods Numerical values belong in the results Indications for H. pylori positive patients should
be defined as well as pepsinogen Was it possible atrophic gastritis? Usually PPIs should be
stopped 3 weeks before gastroscopic while for H2RB a week is adequate Why have authors
selected a 2 week period for both? Organ dysfunction should be defined Which mental disorders
are accepted? Anxiety and dypression should not be excluded Which scale was used to access
anxiety? Was it accessed after the endoscopy and when? Was the score accessing visibility been
validated? In such a case results should be provided   Were biopsies taken during gastroscopy
to define presence of gastritis and H. pylori infection? Was Syndney protocol used for biopsy
taking? Which methods was use to define H. pylori infection apart from UBT? Statistics for
comparison of parameters with more than two variables is better to utilize ANOVA Power of
the study should be moved in statistics
assistant