Title: Predicting Severity of Inpatient Acute Cholangitis : Combined Neutrophil-to-
Lymphocyte Ratio and Prognostic Nutritional Index
Version: 5 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Ronald Mbiine
Reviewer's report:
Thank you authors on writing this manuscript.
I enjoyed reading your manuscript and found it informative and well written.
I believe it will be highly informative to various readers.
The main concerns that I have are in the methodology:
1. This being a predictive study, there needed to be clarity on how you derived your sample size.
Do you believe your study was sufficiently powered to derive the conclusions above?
2. How did you deal with the missing data and were there adjustements to account for this?
3. Could you also describe other details of your study methods including the study setting,
population etc..
4. A few typing errors that can be corrected.
Title: Predicting Severity of Inpatient Acute Cholangitis : Combined Neutrophil-to-
Lymphocyte Ratio and Prognostic Nutritional Index
Version: 5 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Ronald Mbiine
Reviewer's report:
Thank you authors on writing this manuscript.
I enjoyed reading your manuscript and found it informative and well written.
I believe it will be highly informative to various readers.
The main concerns that I have are in the methodology:
1. This being a predictive study, there needed to be clarity on how you derived your sample size.
Do you believe your study was sufficiently powered to derive the conclusions above?
2. How did you deal with the missing data and were there adjustements to account for this?
3. Could you also describe other details of your study methods including the study setting,
population etc..
4. A few typing errors that can be corrected.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Predicting Severity of Inpatient Acute Cholangitis : Combined Neutrophil-to-
Lymphocyte Ratio and Prognostic Nutritional Index
Version: 5 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Ronald Mbiine
Reviewer's report:
Thank you authors on writing this manuscript.
I enjoyed reading your manuscript and found it informative and well written.
I believe it will be highly informative to various readers.
The main concerns that I have are in the methodology:
1. This being a predictive study, there needed to be clarity on how you derived your sample size.
Do you believe your study was sufficiently powered to derive the conclusions above?
2. How did you deal with the missing data and were there adjustements to account for this?
3. Could you also describe other details of your study methods including the study setting,
population etc..
4. A few typing errors that can be corrected.
assistant