Title: Surgical treatment of chronic pancreatitis with an inflammatory pancreatic head mass: a
retrospective study
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
1.The authors present in their point-to-point answer and in the revised manuscript important
details of the early postoperative complications comparing PD and DPPHR for chronic
pancreatitis with inflammatory mass in the pancreatic head. The in-hospital mortality was 5 %
vs. 0 % following PD resp. DPPHR. The author should include these data in the abstract.
2. The message in ‘Conclusions’ (Abstract and Discussion) is misleading regarding the
advantages of the parenchyma-sparing resection compared to PD in terms of high risk for
complications after PD with a mortality of 5 %, maintenance of the duodenum and upper loop
of jejunum and lower risk of metabolic dysfunctions displayed postoperatively after DPPHR,
when compared to PD.
Title: Surgical treatment of chronic pancreatitis with an inflammatory pancreatic head mass: a
retrospective study
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
1.The authors present in their point-to-point answer and in the revised manuscript important
details of the early postoperative complications comparing PD and DPPHR for chronic
pancreatitis with inflammatory mass in the pancreatic head. The in-hospital mortality was 5 %
vs. 0 % following PD resp. DPPHR. The author should include these data in the abstract.
2. The message in ‘Conclusions’ (Abstract and Discussion) is misleading regarding the
advantages of the parenchyma-sparing resection compared to PD in terms of high risk for
complications after PD with a mortality of 5 %, maintenance of the duodenum and upper loop
of jejunum and lower risk of metabolic dysfunctions displayed postoperatively after DPPHR,
when compared to PD.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Surgical treatment of chronic pancreatitis with an inflammatory pancreatic head mass: a
retrospective study
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
1.The authors present in their point-to-point answer and in the revised manuscript important
details of the early postoperative complications comparing PD and DPPHR for chronic
pancreatitis with inflammatory mass in the pancreatic head. The in-hospital mortality was 5 %
vs. 0 % following PD resp. DPPHR. The author should include these data in the abstract.
2. The message in ‘Conclusions’ (Abstract and Discussion) is misleading regarding the
advantages of the parenchyma-sparing resection compared to PD in terms of high risk for
complications after PD with a mortality of 5 %, maintenance of the duodenum and upper loop
of jejunum and lower risk of metabolic dysfunctions displayed postoperatively after DPPHR,
when compared to PD.
assistant