Title: Gallbladder-preserving polypectomy for gallbladder polyp by embryonic-natural orifice
transumbilical endoscopic surgery with a gastric endoscopy
Version: 2 Date: 29 Nov 2021
Reviewer:  Paul Yeaton
Reviewer's report:
I think this is remarkable.
There are cultural differences that will certainly arise and confuse may readers.
I have the impression that many Chinese wish to retain the gallbladder.
The typical Westerner would consider the gallbladder the most disposable organ in the body,
perhaps more than the appendix.
I don't know how this is best addressed, or if it needs to be addressed at all; most Westerners
reading this will be confused as to why such extraordinary skill was used when the gallbladder
could simply be removed. I am sure such a study could never be replicated in the West; people
would not understand the premise.
The skill of the procedure is elegant, as an example the  hemostatic clip placement - I know few
Americans that could be so precise placing them in the stomach.
Perhaps expanding on the reasons for gallbladder preservation would help many readers in the
West.
I would definitely expand the details of how the procedure was performed, as mentioned in some
of  the earlier comments.
#########
##################
#################
################################
###########################################################################
#######################
################### - ########################
#######################
#################################
Title: Gallbladder-preserving polypectomy for gallbladder polyp by embryonic-natural orifice
transumbilical endoscopic surgery with a gastric endoscopy
Version: 2 Date: 29 Nov 2021
Reviewer:  Paul Yeaton
Reviewer's report:
I think this is remarkable.
There are cultural differences that will certainly arise and confuse may readers.
I have the impression that many Chinese wish to retain the gallbladder.
The typical Westerner would consider the gallbladder the most disposable organ in the body,
perhaps more than the appendix.
I don't know how this is best addressed, or if it needs to be addressed at all; most Westerners
reading this will be confused as to why such extraordinary skill was used when the gallbladder
could simply be removed. I am sure such a study could never be replicated in the West; people
would not understand the premise.
The skill of the procedure is elegant, as an example the  hemostatic clip placement - I know few
Americans that could be so precise placing them in the stomach.
Perhaps expanding on the reasons for gallbladder preservation would help many readers in the
West.
I would definitely expand the details of how the procedure was performed, as mentioned in some
of  the earlier comments.
#########
##################
#################
################################
###########################################################################
#######################
################### - ########################
#######################
#################################
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Gallbladder-preserving polypectomy for gallbladder polyp by embryonic-natural orifice
transumbilical endoscopic surgery with a gastric endoscopy
Version: 2 Date: 29 Nov 2021
Reviewer:  Paul Yeaton
Reviewer's report:
I think this is remarkable.
There are cultural differences that will certainly arise and confuse may readers.
I have the impression that many Chinese wish to retain the gallbladder.
The typical Westerner would consider the gallbladder the most disposable organ in the body,
perhaps more than the appendix.
I don't know how this is best addressed, or if it needs to be addressed at all; most Westerners
reading this will be confused as to why such extraordinary skill was used when the gallbladder
could simply be removed. I am sure such a study could never be replicated in the West; people
would not understand the premise.
The skill of the procedure is elegant, as an example the  hemostatic clip placement - I know few
Americans that could be so precise placing them in the stomach.
Perhaps expanding on the reasons for gallbladder preservation would help many readers in the
West.
I would definitely expand the details of how the procedure was performed, as mentioned in some
of  the earlier comments.
#########
##################
#################
################################
###########################################################################
#######################
################### - ########################
#######################
#################################
assistant