Title: Effect of active wound dressing on postoperative pain and wound healing in patients
undergoing anorectal surgery
Version: 0 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Although authors have described the effect of active wound dressing after anorectal surgery, the
following needs to be clarified:
1) In most western countries, anorectal surgery is perfomed on a day-surgery protocol, and as
such such acive dressing wound not be possible, and considering the cost, such active dressing
is not feasible.
2) There is no detailed mention on what diseases were included in the study, this need to be
clarified. And also there is no description on what kind of surgery was peformed on these
patients.
3) There should be a figure describing how the wound healing rate was measured, because this
is hard to understand, and the character of the wound should differ according to the original
disease on which operation was peformed.
4) Authors
4) Although the study is very interesting and deliberately performed, I do not find it practical
for routine practice in the western atmosphere.
Title: Effect of active wound dressing on postoperative pain and wound healing in patients
undergoing anorectal surgery
Version: 0 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Although authors have described the effect of active wound dressing after anorectal surgery, the
following needs to be clarified:
1) In most western countries, anorectal surgery is perfomed on a day-surgery protocol, and as
such such acive dressing wound not be possible, and considering the cost, such active dressing
is not feasible.
2) There is no detailed mention on what diseases were included in the study, this need to be
clarified. And also there is no description on what kind of surgery was peformed on these
patients.
3) There should be a figure describing how the wound healing rate was measured, because this
is hard to understand, and the character of the wound should differ according to the original
disease on which operation was peformed.
4) Authors
4) Although the study is very interesting and deliberately performed, I do not find it practical
for routine practice in the western atmosphere.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Effect of active wound dressing on postoperative pain and wound healing in patients
undergoing anorectal surgery
Version: 0 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Although authors have described the effect of active wound dressing after anorectal surgery, the
following needs to be clarified:
1) In most western countries, anorectal surgery is perfomed on a day-surgery protocol, and as
such such acive dressing wound not be possible, and considering the cost, such active dressing
is not feasible.
2) There is no detailed mention on what diseases were included in the study, this need to be
clarified. And also there is no description on what kind of surgery was peformed on these
patients.
3) There should be a figure describing how the wound healing rate was measured, because this
is hard to understand, and the character of the wound should differ according to the original
disease on which operation was peformed.
4) Authors
4) Although the study is very interesting and deliberately performed, I do not find it practical
for routine practice in the western atmosphere.
assistant