Title: Magnetic Navigation-Assisted Colonoscopic Enteral Tube Placement in Swine (with
Video): A Preliminary Study
Version: 0 Date: 02 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
# am not sure on what this study is trying to tell us.
The tube did not reach its endpoint - ie the proximal colon, which was the entire purpose.
The comparison  of previously used clips VS the magnetic device  to secure the tube in place is
not clear - is the tube supposed to stay long-term for FMT? And is the patient supposed to stay
permanently attached to the magnet until completion of treatment?
The mentioning of magnetic placement of NJ tubes and how they stay in place is also not
particularly relevant
Title: Magnetic Navigation-Assisted Colonoscopic Enteral Tube Placement in Swine (with
Video): A Preliminary Study
Version: 0 Date: 02 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
# am not sure on what this study is trying to tell us.
The tube did not reach its endpoint - ie the proximal colon, which was the entire purpose.
The comparison  of previously used clips VS the magnetic device  to secure the tube in place is
not clear - is the tube supposed to stay long-term for FMT? And is the patient supposed to stay
permanently attached to the magnet until completion of treatment?
The mentioning of magnetic placement of NJ tubes and how they stay in place is also not
particularly relevant
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Magnetic Navigation-Assisted Colonoscopic Enteral Tube Placement in Swine (with
Video): A Preliminary Study
Version: 0 Date: 02 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
# am not sure on what this study is trying to tell us.
The tube did not reach its endpoint - ie the proximal colon, which was the entire purpose.
The comparison  of previously used clips VS the magnetic device  to secure the tube in place is
not clear - is the tube supposed to stay long-term for FMT? And is the patient supposed to stay
permanently attached to the magnet until completion of treatment?
The mentioning of magnetic placement of NJ tubes and how they stay in place is also not
particularly relevant
assistant