Title: Incidence, risk factors, and predictive modeling of stoma site incisional hernia after
enterostomy closure: A multicenter retrospective cohort study
Version: 3 Date: 24 Apr 2023
Reviewer's report:
In the present manuscript tilted“Incidence, risk factors, and predictive modeling of stoma
site incisional hernia after enterostomy closure: A multicenter retrospective cohort study”#the
authors have explored the incidence and risk factors of SSIH and build a predictive model. The
results showed that age # 68 years, colostomy, BMI #25kg/m2, malignant tumor and emergency
surgery are the independent risk factors for SSIH. Based on the results, a predictive model for
the occurrence of SSIH was constructed to screen high-risk groups of SSIH. For patients at high
risk for SSIH, preventive intervention, such as prophylactic bio-mesh placement combined with
enterostomy closure, can be a feasible option to prevent SSIH occurrence. These findings are
interesting and novel, the results are enlightening to peers. In summary, it is recommended to
give priority to publication.
Title: Incidence, risk factors, and predictive modeling of stoma site incisional hernia after
enterostomy closure: A multicenter retrospective cohort study
Version: 3 Date: 24 Apr 2023
Reviewer's report:
In the present manuscript tilted“Incidence, risk factors, and predictive modeling of stoma
site incisional hernia after enterostomy closure: A multicenter retrospective cohort study”#the
authors have explored the incidence and risk factors of SSIH and build a predictive model. The
results showed that age # 68 years, colostomy, BMI #25kg/m2, malignant tumor and emergency
surgery are the independent risk factors for SSIH. Based on the results, a predictive model for
the occurrence of SSIH was constructed to screen high-risk groups of SSIH. For patients at high
risk for SSIH, preventive intervention, such as prophylactic bio-mesh placement combined with
enterostomy closure, can be a feasible option to prevent SSIH occurrence. These findings are
interesting and novel, the results are enlightening to peers. In summary, it is recommended to
give priority to publication.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Incidence, risk factors, and predictive modeling of stoma site incisional hernia after
enterostomy closure: A multicenter retrospective cohort study
Version: 3 Date: 24 Apr 2023
Reviewer's report:
In the present manuscript tilted“Incidence, risk factors, and predictive modeling of stoma
site incisional hernia after enterostomy closure: A multicenter retrospective cohort study”#the
authors have explored the incidence and risk factors of SSIH and build a predictive model. The
results showed that age # 68 years, colostomy, BMI #25kg/m2, malignant tumor and emergency
surgery are the independent risk factors for SSIH. Based on the results, a predictive model for
the occurrence of SSIH was constructed to screen high-risk groups of SSIH. For patients at high
risk for SSIH, preventive intervention, such as prophylactic bio-mesh placement combined with
enterostomy closure, can be a feasible option to prevent SSIH occurrence. These findings are
interesting and novel, the results are enlightening to peers. In summary, it is recommended to
give priority to publication.
assistant