Title: Poly-#-caprolactone scaffold as staple-line reinforcement of rectal anastomosis: An
experimental piglet study
Version: 1 Date: 10 Dec 2023
Reviewer:  Akira Umemura
Reviewer's report:
The authors could not demonstrate the speriority of PCL scaffold in rectal anastomosis. These
results can not be lead to the conclusion of sfae use of scaffold...Usual rectal anastomosis is
perfomed under severe edematous and inflammatory condition; therefore, you should duplicate
the same condition as usual clinical practice.
Title: Poly-#-caprolactone scaffold as staple-line reinforcement of rectal anastomosis: An
experimental piglet study
Version: 1 Date: 10 Dec 2023
Reviewer:  Akira Umemura
Reviewer's report:
The authors could not demonstrate the speriority of PCL scaffold in rectal anastomosis. These
results can not be lead to the conclusion of sfae use of scaffold...Usual rectal anastomosis is
perfomed under severe edematous and inflammatory condition; therefore, you should duplicate
the same condition as usual clinical practice.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Poly-#-caprolactone scaffold as staple-line reinforcement of rectal anastomosis: An
experimental piglet study
Version: 1 Date: 10 Dec 2023
Reviewer:  Akira Umemura
Reviewer's report:
The authors could not demonstrate the speriority of PCL scaffold in rectal anastomosis. These
results can not be lead to the conclusion of sfae use of scaffold...Usual rectal anastomosis is
perfomed under severe edematous and inflammatory condition; therefore, you should duplicate
the same condition as usual clinical practice.
assistant