Title: A nomogram for predicting cancer-specific survival for elderly patients with gallbladder
cancer
Version: 2 Date: 01 Oct 2022
Reviewer's report:
This is a manuscript that looks into “A nomogram for predicting cancer-specific survival for
elderly patients with gallbladder cancer.  It is a revised manuscript which addressed some of
the key concerns that were raised earlier. It is a subject of interest to relevant clinician. One
limitation remains in that it is a nomogram only for elderly patients (>65).  Another limitation
is that it is based on the SEER database which includes incomplete data as some patients with
chemotherapy (yes/no/unknown) are unable to be excluded due to the incomplete data set.
Title: A nomogram for predicting cancer-specific survival for elderly patients with gallbladder
cancer
Version: 2 Date: 01 Oct 2022
Reviewer's report:
This is a manuscript that looks into “A nomogram for predicting cancer-specific survival for
elderly patients with gallbladder cancer.  It is a revised manuscript which addressed some of
the key concerns that were raised earlier. It is a subject of interest to relevant clinician. One
limitation remains in that it is a nomogram only for elderly patients (>65).  Another limitation
is that it is based on the SEER database which includes incomplete data as some patients with
chemotherapy (yes/no/unknown) are unable to be excluded due to the incomplete data set.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: A nomogram for predicting cancer-specific survival for elderly patients with gallbladder
cancer
Version: 2 Date: 01 Oct 2022
Reviewer's report:
This is a manuscript that looks into “A nomogram for predicting cancer-specific survival for
elderly patients with gallbladder cancer.  It is a revised manuscript which addressed some of
the key concerns that were raised earlier. It is a subject of interest to relevant clinician. One
limitation remains in that it is a nomogram only for elderly patients (>65).  Another limitation
is that it is based on the SEER database which includes incomplete data as some patients with
chemotherapy (yes/no/unknown) are unable to be excluded due to the incomplete data set.
assistant