Title: Epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal cancer and advanced adenoma: a
single center experience in Jordan
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript was improved a lot after the comments of the colleagues from the first review
round.  The are lot of limitations of the study, which was mentioned, however the study is
important in the context of Jordan.
Here are several minor points showed be addressed:
1. Mean BMI of 46 seems to be Unlogical, can't be most of the patients with severe obesity in
the cohort. Please recheck it. Maybe you have few outsiders in the cohort that make this high
number.
2. In table 1, p-values were written as 0.000, better to write <0.001
3. Results sections, for better flow, the multivariate analysis should be the last part presented in
the results section and not the polyp characteristics.
4. Conclusions of the manuscript: the conclusion of the manuscript is nice, but not related the
study's findings. The authors need to write a conclusion in the context of the study findings.
Title: Epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal cancer and advanced adenoma: a
single center experience in Jordan
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript was improved a lot after the comments of the colleagues from the first review
round.  The are lot of limitations of the study, which was mentioned, however the study is
important in the context of Jordan.
Here are several minor points showed be addressed:
1. Mean BMI of 46 seems to be Unlogical, can't be most of the patients with severe obesity in
the cohort. Please recheck it. Maybe you have few outsiders in the cohort that make this high
number.
2. In table 1, p-values were written as 0.000, better to write <0.001
3. Results sections, for better flow, the multivariate analysis should be the last part presented in
the results section and not the polyp characteristics.
4. Conclusions of the manuscript: the conclusion of the manuscript is nice, but not related the
study's findings. The authors need to write a conclusion in the context of the study findings.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Epidemiology and clinical characteristics of colorectal cancer and advanced adenoma: a
single center experience in Jordan
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript was improved a lot after the comments of the colleagues from the first review
round.  The are lot of limitations of the study, which was mentioned, however the study is
important in the context of Jordan.
Here are several minor points showed be addressed:
1. Mean BMI of 46 seems to be Unlogical, can't be most of the patients with severe obesity in
the cohort. Please recheck it. Maybe you have few outsiders in the cohort that make this high
number.
2. In table 1, p-values were written as 0.000, better to write <0.001
3. Results sections, for better flow, the multivariate analysis should be the last part presented in
the results section and not the polyp characteristics.
4. Conclusions of the manuscript: the conclusion of the manuscript is nice, but not related the
study's findings. The authors need to write a conclusion in the context of the study findings.
assistant