Title: The intestinal flora and nutritional status and immune function characteristics of obese
colon cancer patients
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2023
Reviewer:  Concetta Finocchiaro
Reviewer's report:
The paper has some shortcomings in the materials and methods:
- it is not written how long the patients are followed, we talk about survival curves but the
observation period of the study is not described
- the methods always talk about obese patients but there are no references to the BMI or weight
of the patients
- the changes in the presence of individual bacteria is not used as a method to interpret the
changes in the microbiota which are more complex and determined with other methods
- to be accepted they must better explain the materials and methods
Title: The intestinal flora and nutritional status and immune function characteristics of obese
colon cancer patients
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2023
Reviewer:  Concetta Finocchiaro
Reviewer's report:
The paper has some shortcomings in the materials and methods:
- it is not written how long the patients are followed, we talk about survival curves but the
observation period of the study is not described
- the methods always talk about obese patients but there are no references to the BMI or weight
of the patients
- the changes in the presence of individual bacteria is not used as a method to interpret the
changes in the microbiota which are more complex and determined with other methods
- to be accepted they must better explain the materials and methods
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The intestinal flora and nutritional status and immune function characteristics of obese
colon cancer patients
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2023
Reviewer:  Concetta Finocchiaro
Reviewer's report:
The paper has some shortcomings in the materials and methods:
- it is not written how long the patients are followed, we talk about survival curves but the
observation period of the study is not described
- the methods always talk about obese patients but there are no references to the BMI or weight
of the patients
- the changes in the presence of individual bacteria is not used as a method to interpret the
changes in the microbiota which are more complex and determined with other methods
- to be accepted they must better explain the materials and methods
assistant