Title: Meta-analysis of the Effectiveness of Early Endoscopic Treatment of Acute Biliary
Pancreatitis based on Lightweight Deep Learning Model
Version: 1 Date: 19 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
The timing of ERCP in acute biliary pancreatitis is import in clinical practice. I think this is
well written article with proper study design and analytic method. There are several points to
be clarified and revised.
Major
1. Could you present the comparison of post-ERCP mortality and morbidiy subgroup analysis
according to the severity of acute pancreatitis?
2. How the result “the meta-analysis demonstrated that no remarkable differences were detected
in the incidence of complications, mortality, and operation time between patients undergoing
ERCP in early stage and those receiving delayed ERCP.” supports the conclusion “treatment of
biliary pancreatitis with early ERCP was very safe”
Minor
1. Line 126-127, “foeward” should be corrected to “forward”.
Title: Meta-analysis of the Effectiveness of Early Endoscopic Treatment of Acute Biliary
Pancreatitis based on Lightweight Deep Learning Model
Version: 1 Date: 19 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
The timing of ERCP in acute biliary pancreatitis is import in clinical practice. I think this is
well written article with proper study design and analytic method. There are several points to
be clarified and revised.
Major
1. Could you present the comparison of post-ERCP mortality and morbidiy subgroup analysis
according to the severity of acute pancreatitis?
2. How the result “the meta-analysis demonstrated that no remarkable differences were detected
in the incidence of complications, mortality, and operation time between patients undergoing
ERCP in early stage and those receiving delayed ERCP.” supports the conclusion “treatment of
biliary pancreatitis with early ERCP was very safe”
Minor
1. Line 126-127, “foeward” should be corrected to “forward”.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Meta-analysis of the Effectiveness of Early Endoscopic Treatment of Acute Biliary
Pancreatitis based on Lightweight Deep Learning Model
Version: 1 Date: 19 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
The timing of ERCP in acute biliary pancreatitis is import in clinical practice. I think this is
well written article with proper study design and analytic method. There are several points to
be clarified and revised.
Major
1. Could you present the comparison of post-ERCP mortality and morbidiy subgroup analysis
according to the severity of acute pancreatitis?
2. How the result “the meta-analysis demonstrated that no remarkable differences were detected
in the incidence of complications, mortality, and operation time between patients undergoing
ERCP in early stage and those receiving delayed ERCP.” supports the conclusion “treatment of
biliary pancreatitis with early ERCP was very safe”
Minor
1. Line 126-127, “foeward” should be corrected to “forward”.
assistant