Title: Optimal Endoscopy Timing in Elderly Patients Presenting with Acute Non-Variceal
Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding.
Version: 13 Date: 24 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract  Instead of low Ht is better to give a certain value or percentange of drop In the results
section is better to provide numerical values than qualitative description Early intervention
group should be described separately for younger and elder patients Methods Was there any
alternative for immergency angiography or CT angiography for patients failed to stabilize
despite intensive resuscitation? Which were the criteria for operational treatment ? Were any
patients with high risk stigmata undergone second look endoscopy? Comorbidities should be
defined Statistics Power of the study should be calculated Results Significant numerical values
should be presented in the text Uni and multivariated analysis is sufficient for all primary
and secondary end points Comparison between young and elderly patients should be restricted
mainly in an introductory table since it is not the main objective of the study Some pictures
could be introduced
Title: Optimal Endoscopy Timing in Elderly Patients Presenting with Acute Non-Variceal
Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding.
Version: 13 Date: 24 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract  Instead of low Ht is better to give a certain value or percentange of drop In the results
section is better to provide numerical values than qualitative description Early intervention
group should be described separately for younger and elder patients Methods Was there any
alternative for immergency angiography or CT angiography for patients failed to stabilize
despite intensive resuscitation? Which were the criteria for operational treatment ? Were any
patients with high risk stigmata undergone second look endoscopy? Comorbidities should be
defined Statistics Power of the study should be calculated Results Significant numerical values
should be presented in the text Uni and multivariated analysis is sufficient for all primary
and secondary end points Comparison between young and elderly patients should be restricted
mainly in an introductory table since it is not the main objective of the study Some pictures
could be introduced
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Optimal Endoscopy Timing in Elderly Patients Presenting with Acute Non-Variceal
Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding.
Version: 13 Date: 24 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract  Instead of low Ht is better to give a certain value or percentange of drop In the results
section is better to provide numerical values than qualitative description Early intervention
group should be described separately for younger and elder patients Methods Was there any
alternative for immergency angiography or CT angiography for patients failed to stabilize
despite intensive resuscitation? Which were the criteria for operational treatment ? Were any
patients with high risk stigmata undergone second look endoscopy? Comorbidities should be
defined Statistics Power of the study should be calculated Results Significant numerical values
should be presented in the text Uni and multivariated analysis is sufficient for all primary
and secondary end points Comparison between young and elderly patients should be restricted
mainly in an introductory table since it is not the main objective of the study Some pictures
could be introduced
assistant