Title: Relationship Between Gastric Mucosal Atrophy, Cystic Dilatation, and Histopathological
Characteristics
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract constraction refers to a review article Nevetheless it is an original paper based on
ESD findings Methods should provide details on characteristics of the study population, ESD
performed and biopsy preparation and analysis  Results should provide the findings Numerical
values belong there and not in methods section Methods Gastric biopsies and ESD samples
does not consist a homogeneous sample  Demographic and clinical charasteristics of the
study population should be presented as well as any structural constracted questionnaire used
Approval of the study from a relevant Scientific board and compliance to Helsinki regulations
is mandatory More details should be provided for histological findings stratification Statistical
analysis methods used should be described as well as study power calculation Logistic regression
analysis evaluating the influence of patients characteristics would be useful Results section 2 of
results should be focused in patients findings Discussion belongs to the relevant section  Section
3 Some part of it belongs to methods and some part to the discussion the same is valid for section
4 Authors should provide their findings
Title: Relationship Between Gastric Mucosal Atrophy, Cystic Dilatation, and Histopathological
Characteristics
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract constraction refers to a review article Nevetheless it is an original paper based on
ESD findings Methods should provide details on characteristics of the study population, ESD
performed and biopsy preparation and analysis  Results should provide the findings Numerical
values belong there and not in methods section Methods Gastric biopsies and ESD samples
does not consist a homogeneous sample  Demographic and clinical charasteristics of the
study population should be presented as well as any structural constracted questionnaire used
Approval of the study from a relevant Scientific board and compliance to Helsinki regulations
is mandatory More details should be provided for histological findings stratification Statistical
analysis methods used should be described as well as study power calculation Logistic regression
analysis evaluating the influence of patients characteristics would be useful Results section 2 of
results should be focused in patients findings Discussion belongs to the relevant section  Section
3 Some part of it belongs to methods and some part to the discussion the same is valid for section
4 Authors should provide their findings
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Relationship Between Gastric Mucosal Atrophy, Cystic Dilatation, and Histopathological
Characteristics
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer:  Panagiotis Tsibouris
Reviewer's report:
Abstract constraction refers to a review article Nevetheless it is an original paper based on
ESD findings Methods should provide details on characteristics of the study population, ESD
performed and biopsy preparation and analysis  Results should provide the findings Numerical
values belong there and not in methods section Methods Gastric biopsies and ESD samples
does not consist a homogeneous sample  Demographic and clinical charasteristics of the
study population should be presented as well as any structural constracted questionnaire used
Approval of the study from a relevant Scientific board and compliance to Helsinki regulations
is mandatory More details should be provided for histological findings stratification Statistical
analysis methods used should be described as well as study power calculation Logistic regression
analysis evaluating the influence of patients characteristics would be useful Results section 2 of
results should be focused in patients findings Discussion belongs to the relevant section  Section
3 Some part of it belongs to methods and some part to the discussion the same is valid for section
4 Authors should provide their findings
assistant