Title: Who would avoid severe adverse events from nasointestinal tube in small bowel
obstruction?—a matched case-control study
Version: 4 Date: 29 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
revision is necessary.
Response to point-to-point response
1. Ok for changing distended large bowel with distended small bowel. The authors did not answer
about the use of gastrograffin to treat SBO
2. The authors included patients presenting with different etiology that makes the study
very heterogeneous!!! Patients with tumor or hernia seem very different from patients with
adhesions… That significantly decrease the value of this study.
3. The authors did not answer to the question.
4. Perhaps we need to wait for the randomized study to publish these results!!!
5. Waiting for randomized study to answer this topic…
6. Ok for your answer…
Title: Who would avoid severe adverse events from nasointestinal tube in small bowel
obstruction?—a matched case-control study
Version: 4 Date: 29 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
revision is necessary.
Response to point-to-point response
1. Ok for changing distended large bowel with distended small bowel. The authors did not answer
about the use of gastrograffin to treat SBO
2. The authors included patients presenting with different etiology that makes the study
very heterogeneous!!! Patients with tumor or hernia seem very different from patients with
adhesions… That significantly decrease the value of this study.
3. The authors did not answer to the question.
4. Perhaps we need to wait for the randomized study to publish these results!!!
5. Waiting for randomized study to answer this topic…
6. Ok for your answer…
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Who would avoid severe adverse events from nasointestinal tube in small bowel
obstruction?—a matched case-control study
Version: 4 Date: 29 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
revision is necessary.
Response to point-to-point response
1. Ok for changing distended large bowel with distended small bowel. The authors did not answer
about the use of gastrograffin to treat SBO
2. The authors included patients presenting with different etiology that makes the study
very heterogeneous!!! Patients with tumor or hernia seem very different from patients with
adhesions… That significantly decrease the value of this study.
3. The authors did not answer to the question.
4. Perhaps we need to wait for the randomized study to publish these results!!!
5. Waiting for randomized study to answer this topic…
6. Ok for your answer…
assistant