Title: Diagnosis and Treatment of Hemothorax Following Local Ablation in Patients with
Primary Liver Cancer
Version: 4 Date: 09 May 2025
Reviewer's report:
The entire study is based on only seven cases, which severely limits the generalizability and
statistical power. While rare complications merit case aggregation, this dataset is too limited
to draw meaningful clinical inferences or justify definitive recommendations Many sections
are excessively wordy and repeat information. For instance, the clinical presentation and
hemoglobin discussion could be condensed significantly. This detracts from the scientific clarity
and makes the manuscript feel padded.
Title: Diagnosis and Treatment of Hemothorax Following Local Ablation in Patients with
Primary Liver Cancer
Version: 4 Date: 09 May 2025
Reviewer's report:
The entire study is based on only seven cases, which severely limits the generalizability and
statistical power. While rare complications merit case aggregation, this dataset is too limited
to draw meaningful clinical inferences or justify definitive recommendations Many sections
are excessively wordy and repeat information. For instance, the clinical presentation and
hemoglobin discussion could be condensed significantly. This detracts from the scientific clarity
and makes the manuscript feel padded.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Diagnosis and Treatment of Hemothorax Following Local Ablation in Patients with
Primary Liver Cancer
Version: 4 Date: 09 May 2025
Reviewer's report:
The entire study is based on only seven cases, which severely limits the generalizability and
statistical power. While rare complications merit case aggregation, this dataset is too limited
to draw meaningful clinical inferences or justify definitive recommendations Many sections
are excessively wordy and repeat information. For instance, the clinical presentation and
hemoglobin discussion could be condensed significantly. This detracts from the scientific clarity
and makes the manuscript feel padded.
assistant