Title: Effect of Biliopancreatic Tree Anatomy on Development of Acute Gallstone Pancreatitis
Version: 1 Date: 19 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Piyush Somani
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
Thanks for the manuscript.
Can you enumerate more on the normal anatomy of Common bile duct and the pancreatic duct?
Please get descriptive figures.
Can you write more about the different biliary pancreatic anomalies? Please make figures on
different anomalies.
Please mention about different anatomical variations of cystic duct in relation to common bile
duct with their percentage enumerated in anatomy textbooks with diagrams in normal subjects.
The MRCP images can be of better quality with proper labelling.
Please mention about the name and tesla of your MRI machine.
There are missing commas in the sentences. Please check grammar in few sentences.
Please have detailed discussion of previous studies on the same topic and comparison between
your study and previous studies and what's new in your study.
Please make comparison table between your study and previous studies on role of bilio-
pancreatic anatomy in gall stone pancreatitis.
In your 'DISCUSSION section', please discuss more about the normal anatomy along with
variations with previous studies from the radiology literature.
If possible, please have on anatomy doctor as your co-author to help you with anatomy literature
and data/images/figures.
Title: Effect of Biliopancreatic Tree Anatomy on Development of Acute Gallstone Pancreatitis
Version: 1 Date: 19 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Piyush Somani
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
Thanks for the manuscript.
Can you enumerate more on the normal anatomy of Common bile duct and the pancreatic duct?
Please get descriptive figures.
Can you write more about the different biliary pancreatic anomalies? Please make figures on
different anomalies.
Please mention about different anatomical variations of cystic duct in relation to common bile
duct with their percentage enumerated in anatomy textbooks with diagrams in normal subjects.
The MRCP images can be of better quality with proper labelling.
Please mention about the name and tesla of your MRI machine.
There are missing commas in the sentences. Please check grammar in few sentences.
Please have detailed discussion of previous studies on the same topic and comparison between
your study and previous studies and what's new in your study.
Please make comparison table between your study and previous studies on role of bilio-
pancreatic anatomy in gall stone pancreatitis.
In your 'DISCUSSION section', please discuss more about the normal anatomy along with
variations with previous studies from the radiology literature.
If possible, please have on anatomy doctor as your co-author to help you with anatomy literature
and data/images/figures.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Effect of Biliopancreatic Tree Anatomy on Development of Acute Gallstone Pancreatitis
Version: 1 Date: 19 Nov 2024
Reviewer:  Piyush Somani
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
Thanks for the manuscript.
Can you enumerate more on the normal anatomy of Common bile duct and the pancreatic duct?
Please get descriptive figures.
Can you write more about the different biliary pancreatic anomalies? Please make figures on
different anomalies.
Please mention about different anatomical variations of cystic duct in relation to common bile
duct with their percentage enumerated in anatomy textbooks with diagrams in normal subjects.
The MRCP images can be of better quality with proper labelling.
Please mention about the name and tesla of your MRI machine.
There are missing commas in the sentences. Please check grammar in few sentences.
Please have detailed discussion of previous studies on the same topic and comparison between
your study and previous studies and what's new in your study.
Please make comparison table between your study and previous studies on role of bilio-
pancreatic anatomy in gall stone pancreatitis.
In your 'DISCUSSION section', please discuss more about the normal anatomy along with
variations with previous studies from the radiology literature.
If possible, please have on anatomy doctor as your co-author to help you with anatomy literature
and data/images/figures.
assistant