Title: Evaluating the Efficacy of Different Volume Resuscitation Strategies in Acute
Pancreatitis Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 21 Jan 2024
Reviewer's report:
You have processed through a meta-analysis the majority of studies regarding volume
resuscitation in severe acute pancreatitits. That what I would emphasize is the comparison
between early and late fluid resuscitation.
You also mentioned the type of infused crystalloids, but I didn't find anything on balanced
crystalloids.
The meta-analysis was detailed and in your Conclusion you emphasize "the lack of robustness of
studies that vividly and analytically provided a uniform comparison between low vs. moderate
vs. high fluid therapy, this study recommends further research, including recent studies with
high methodological quality, to validate the findings of this study". I deffinitely agree with that.
Title: Evaluating the Efficacy of Different Volume Resuscitation Strategies in Acute
Pancreatitis Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 21 Jan 2024
Reviewer's report:
You have processed through a meta-analysis the majority of studies regarding volume
resuscitation in severe acute pancreatitits. That what I would emphasize is the comparison
between early and late fluid resuscitation.
You also mentioned the type of infused crystalloids, but I didn't find anything on balanced
crystalloids.
The meta-analysis was detailed and in your Conclusion you emphasize "the lack of robustness of
studies that vividly and analytically provided a uniform comparison between low vs. moderate
vs. high fluid therapy, this study recommends further research, including recent studies with
high methodological quality, to validate the findings of this study". I deffinitely agree with that.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Evaluating the Efficacy of Different Volume Resuscitation Strategies in Acute
Pancreatitis Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 21 Jan 2024
Reviewer's report:
You have processed through a meta-analysis the majority of studies regarding volume
resuscitation in severe acute pancreatitits. That what I would emphasize is the comparison
between early and late fluid resuscitation.
You also mentioned the type of infused crystalloids, but I didn't find anything on balanced
crystalloids.
The meta-analysis was detailed and in your Conclusion you emphasize "the lack of robustness of
studies that vividly and analytically provided a uniform comparison between low vs. moderate
vs. high fluid therapy, this study recommends further research, including recent studies with
high methodological quality, to validate the findings of this study". I deffinitely agree with that.
assistant