Title: Clinico-pathological study of esophageal mucoepidermoid carcinoma: a 10-year survival
from a single center
Version: 1 Date: 26 Sep 2023
Reviewer's report:
It was very pleasant to read and review the manuscript titled "Clinico-pathological study of
esophageal mucoepidermoid carcinoma: a 10-year survival from a single center" submitted for
publication in "BMC Gastroenterology".The article is original, well written and the relationship
studies is interesting. However, if you don't mind, I would like to ask for some minor
suggesstions:
A. Please write a specific paragraph concerning the aim of your study instead of including it
in the previous one.
B. Please add the full noun of SPSS
C. 147—174  The author spends a lot of sentences describing how MECE is prone to
misdiagnosis, but how is it related to the clinical pathological studies? It is advised to reduce
some of the explanation content
D. 175—192#The author spends a lot of sentences talking about immune indicators#I hope the
author can consider deleting some of the details.
E. The article only conducted univariate analysis, multivariate analysis also should be
considered.
F. Survival Analysis in different T and N stages should be considered. and the survival curve
was not aesthetically pleasing
I wish the authors good luck.
Title: Clinico-pathological study of esophageal mucoepidermoid carcinoma: a 10-year survival
from a single center
Version: 1 Date: 26 Sep 2023
Reviewer's report:
It was very pleasant to read and review the manuscript titled "Clinico-pathological study of
esophageal mucoepidermoid carcinoma: a 10-year survival from a single center" submitted for
publication in "BMC Gastroenterology".The article is original, well written and the relationship
studies is interesting. However, if you don't mind, I would like to ask for some minor
suggesstions:
A. Please write a specific paragraph concerning the aim of your study instead of including it
in the previous one.
B. Please add the full noun of SPSS
C. 147—174  The author spends a lot of sentences describing how MECE is prone to
misdiagnosis, but how is it related to the clinical pathological studies? It is advised to reduce
some of the explanation content
D. 175—192#The author spends a lot of sentences talking about immune indicators#I hope the
author can consider deleting some of the details.
E. The article only conducted univariate analysis, multivariate analysis also should be
considered.
F. Survival Analysis in different T and N stages should be considered. and the survival curve
was not aesthetically pleasing
I wish the authors good luck.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinico-pathological study of esophageal mucoepidermoid carcinoma: a 10-year survival
from a single center
Version: 1 Date: 26 Sep 2023
Reviewer's report:
It was very pleasant to read and review the manuscript titled "Clinico-pathological study of
esophageal mucoepidermoid carcinoma: a 10-year survival from a single center" submitted for
publication in "BMC Gastroenterology".The article is original, well written and the relationship
studies is interesting. However, if you don't mind, I would like to ask for some minor
suggesstions:
A. Please write a specific paragraph concerning the aim of your study instead of including it
in the previous one.
B. Please add the full noun of SPSS
C. 147—174  The author spends a lot of sentences describing how MECE is prone to
misdiagnosis, but how is it related to the clinical pathological studies? It is advised to reduce
some of the explanation content
D. 175—192#The author spends a lot of sentences talking about immune indicators#I hope the
author can consider deleting some of the details.
E. The article only conducted univariate analysis, multivariate analysis also should be
considered.
F. Survival Analysis in different T and N stages should be considered. and the survival curve
was not aesthetically pleasing
I wish the authors good luck.
assistant