Reviewer's report
Title:Hemodynamic effects of plasma-expansion with hyperoncotic albumin in
cirrhotic patients with renal failure. A prospective interventional study.
Version: 2Date:24 July 2008
Reviewer: Jochen Renner
Reviewer's report:
I have read the previous comments of the other reviewer and the author`s
response. To me it seems that most of the concerns have been addressed
appropriately. Points of major criticism, for example, the concerns about the
interpretation that SVRI as an indicator of afterload was the best predictor of fluid
responsivenesss have been deleted from the discussion section.
It would be helpful if a native speaker could be involved in the editng of the
manuscript. I quite believe that this would be in agreement with the other author.
In addition I have only minor concerns.
Reviewer's report
Title:Hemodynamic effects of plasma-expansion with hyperoncotic albumin in
cirrhotic patients with renal failure. A prospective interventional study.
Version: 2Date:24 July 2008
Reviewer: Jochen Renner
Reviewer's report:
I have read the previous comments of the other reviewer and the author`s
response. To me it seems that most of the concerns have been addressed
appropriately. Points of major criticism, for example, the concerns about the
interpretation that SVRI as an indicator of afterload was the best predictor of fluid
responsivenesss have been deleted from the discussion section.
It would be helpful if a native speaker could be involved in the editng of the
manuscript. I quite believe that this would be in agreement with the other author.
In addition I have only minor concerns.
Please review this paper.
user
Reviewer's report
Title:Hemodynamic effects of plasma-expansion with hyperoncotic albumin in
cirrhotic patients with renal failure. A prospective interventional study.
Version: 2Date:24 July 2008
Reviewer: Jochen Renner
Reviewer's report:
I have read the previous comments of the other reviewer and the author`s
response. To me it seems that most of the concerns have been addressed
appropriately. Points of major criticism, for example, the concerns about the
interpretation that SVRI as an indicator of afterload was the best predictor of fluid
responsivenesss have been deleted from the discussion section.
It would be helpful if a native speaker could be involved in the editng of the
manuscript. I quite believe that this would be in agreement with the other author.
In addition I have only minor concerns.
assistant