Title: A Novel Nomogram Based on inflammatory-nutritional Biomarkers For Gallbladder
Cancer after Surgical Resection
Version: 2 Date: 16 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your diligent and thorough revisions to the manuscript titled "[ A Novel
Nomogram Based on inflammatory-nutritional Biomarkers For Gallbladder Cancer after
Surgical Resection]." I appreciate the effort and attention to detail you have demonstrated in
addressing the concerns and suggestions I previously raised.
The inclusion of the Schoenfeld residuals analysis results in the supplementary materials has
significantly strengthened the robustness of the findings. Additionally, the detailed explanation
on how the linear predictor values were converted to the simplified risk scores (points) has
enhanced the clarity and comprehensibility of the methodology.
The revised manuscript now provides a comprehensive and well-substantiated predictive
nomogram for overall survival based on inflammatory biomarkers, maintaining the high
standards of clarity and organization that I initially commended.
I am pleased to inform you that I recommend accepting this manuscript for publication.
Congratulations on this valuable contribution to cancer research.
Title: A Novel Nomogram Based on inflammatory-nutritional Biomarkers For Gallbladder
Cancer after Surgical Resection
Version: 2 Date: 16 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your diligent and thorough revisions to the manuscript titled "[ A Novel
Nomogram Based on inflammatory-nutritional Biomarkers For Gallbladder Cancer after
Surgical Resection]." I appreciate the effort and attention to detail you have demonstrated in
addressing the concerns and suggestions I previously raised.
The inclusion of the Schoenfeld residuals analysis results in the supplementary materials has
significantly strengthened the robustness of the findings. Additionally, the detailed explanation
on how the linear predictor values were converted to the simplified risk scores (points) has
enhanced the clarity and comprehensibility of the methodology.
The revised manuscript now provides a comprehensive and well-substantiated predictive
nomogram for overall survival based on inflammatory biomarkers, maintaining the high
standards of clarity and organization that I initially commended.
I am pleased to inform you that I recommend accepting this manuscript for publication.
Congratulations on this valuable contribution to cancer research.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: A Novel Nomogram Based on inflammatory-nutritional Biomarkers For Gallbladder
Cancer after Surgical Resection
Version: 2 Date: 16 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your diligent and thorough revisions to the manuscript titled "[ A Novel
Nomogram Based on inflammatory-nutritional Biomarkers For Gallbladder Cancer after
Surgical Resection]." I appreciate the effort and attention to detail you have demonstrated in
addressing the concerns and suggestions I previously raised.
The inclusion of the Schoenfeld residuals analysis results in the supplementary materials has
significantly strengthened the robustness of the findings. Additionally, the detailed explanation
on how the linear predictor values were converted to the simplified risk scores (points) has
enhanced the clarity and comprehensibility of the methodology.
The revised manuscript now provides a comprehensive and well-substantiated predictive
nomogram for overall survival based on inflammatory biomarkers, maintaining the high
standards of clarity and organization that I initially commended.
I am pleased to inform you that I recommend accepting this manuscript for publication.
Congratulations on this valuable contribution to cancer research.
assistant