Title: Using a nomogram based on the controlling nutritional status score to predict prognosis
after surgery in patients with resectable gastric cancer
Version: 1 Date: 01 May 2024
Reviewer's report:
I am pleased to report that the authors have diligently addressed all of the concerns raised
during the previous review cycle. Their efforts have resulted in a significantly improved paper
that now meets the expectations outlined by the reviewers. The authors have demonstrated a
thorough understanding of the feedback provided, and they have made substantial revisions
to the manuscript accordingly. They have clarified their methodology, strengthened their
arguments, and provided additional evidence where necessary. Moreover, they have addressed
any ambiguities in their findings and conclusions, ensuring the coherence and robustness of their
work. Overall, the revisions have notably enhanced the quality and impact of the paper. It now
presents a comprehensive and compelling contribution to the field, deserving of publication in
BMC Gastroenterology. Therefore, I fully recommend the publication of this manuscript.
Title: Using a nomogram based on the controlling nutritional status score to predict prognosis
after surgery in patients with resectable gastric cancer
Version: 1 Date: 01 May 2024
Reviewer's report:
I am pleased to report that the authors have diligently addressed all of the concerns raised
during the previous review cycle. Their efforts have resulted in a significantly improved paper
that now meets the expectations outlined by the reviewers. The authors have demonstrated a
thorough understanding of the feedback provided, and they have made substantial revisions
to the manuscript accordingly. They have clarified their methodology, strengthened their
arguments, and provided additional evidence where necessary. Moreover, they have addressed
any ambiguities in their findings and conclusions, ensuring the coherence and robustness of their
work. Overall, the revisions have notably enhanced the quality and impact of the paper. It now
presents a comprehensive and compelling contribution to the field, deserving of publication in
BMC Gastroenterology. Therefore, I fully recommend the publication of this manuscript.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Using a nomogram based on the controlling nutritional status score to predict prognosis
after surgery in patients with resectable gastric cancer
Version: 1 Date: 01 May 2024
Reviewer's report:
I am pleased to report that the authors have diligently addressed all of the concerns raised
during the previous review cycle. Their efforts have resulted in a significantly improved paper
that now meets the expectations outlined by the reviewers. The authors have demonstrated a
thorough understanding of the feedback provided, and they have made substantial revisions
to the manuscript accordingly. They have clarified their methodology, strengthened their
arguments, and provided additional evidence where necessary. Moreover, they have addressed
any ambiguities in their findings and conclusions, ensuring the coherence and robustness of their
work. Overall, the revisions have notably enhanced the quality and impact of the paper. It now
presents a comprehensive and compelling contribution to the field, deserving of publication in
BMC Gastroenterology. Therefore, I fully recommend the publication of this manuscript.
assistant