Title: Preoperative Optimization Strategy Management Model Applied in Gallbladder Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 06 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
- Interesting concept and viewpoint, well structure study and analysis
- Interchangeability of regular and general admission terms may seem to confuse readers, better
to be uniform throughout the manuscript
- How do you explain the higher age population in the general hospitalization group which seems
to significantly affect length of stay and postoperative recovery time
- Better definition of when these surgeries were performed - elective cases or emergency cases
since cholecystectomy done during same admission to acute cholecystitis will have higher length
of stay and costs.
- Explanation to significant difference among preoperative preparation time with and without
underlying diseases at pre-hospitalization since no difference is noted in median and range
values.
- A table depicting the <65 years and >65 years in the general/regular admission group will also
be interesting to look at.
- An extrapolated thought and topic for further research will be the influence of distance to care
being significant factor affecting both groups with people from farther distances prefer being
admitted rather than going the pre-hospitalization route. Similar to effect of area deprivation
index (ADI) on outcomes of care in US.
Title: Preoperative Optimization Strategy Management Model Applied in Gallbladder Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 06 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
- Interesting concept and viewpoint, well structure study and analysis
- Interchangeability of regular and general admission terms may seem to confuse readers, better
to be uniform throughout the manuscript
- How do you explain the higher age population in the general hospitalization group which seems
to significantly affect length of stay and postoperative recovery time
- Better definition of when these surgeries were performed - elective cases or emergency cases
since cholecystectomy done during same admission to acute cholecystitis will have higher length
of stay and costs.
- Explanation to significant difference among preoperative preparation time with and without
underlying diseases at pre-hospitalization since no difference is noted in median and range
values.
- A table depicting the <65 years and >65 years in the general/regular admission group will also
be interesting to look at.
- An extrapolated thought and topic for further research will be the influence of distance to care
being significant factor affecting both groups with people from farther distances prefer being
admitted rather than going the pre-hospitalization route. Similar to effect of area deprivation
index (ADI) on outcomes of care in US.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Preoperative Optimization Strategy Management Model Applied in Gallbladder Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 06 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
- Interesting concept and viewpoint, well structure study and analysis
- Interchangeability of regular and general admission terms may seem to confuse readers, better
to be uniform throughout the manuscript
- How do you explain the higher age population in the general hospitalization group which seems
to significantly affect length of stay and postoperative recovery time
- Better definition of when these surgeries were performed - elective cases or emergency cases
since cholecystectomy done during same admission to acute cholecystitis will have higher length
of stay and costs.
- Explanation to significant difference among preoperative preparation time with and without
underlying diseases at pre-hospitalization since no difference is noted in median and range
values.
- A table depicting the <65 years and >65 years in the general/regular admission group will also
be interesting to look at.
- An extrapolated thought and topic for further research will be the influence of distance to care
being significant factor affecting both groups with people from farther distances prefer being
admitted rather than going the pre-hospitalization route. Similar to effect of area deprivation
index (ADI) on outcomes of care in US.
assistant