Title: Prediction of neoplastic gallbladder polyps in patients with different age level based on
preoperative ultrasound: a multi-center retrospective real-world study
Version: 0 Date: 28 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
The authors described a value of the linear scoring model to predict malignant GPs. The study
included many subjects, and statistical analysis was appropriate. I think it is a valuable report;
however, please revise several points.
In Figure 1A-C, the visibility of the numbers in the non-NP group was limited. I suggest
changing the color of the number or background.
In Fig.2, there are three groups; however, cutoff values were calculated only 10.5 mm and 8.0
mm. The authors should describe each cutoff value for three groups.
Linear scoring systems were described precisely; however, the authors should describe a
simplified method to evaluate the malignant potential for readers. I suggest to add the calculation
formula in the abstract or table.
Title: Prediction of neoplastic gallbladder polyps in patients with different age level based on
preoperative ultrasound: a multi-center retrospective real-world study
Version: 0 Date: 28 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
The authors described a value of the linear scoring model to predict malignant GPs. The study
included many subjects, and statistical analysis was appropriate. I think it is a valuable report;
however, please revise several points.
In Figure 1A-C, the visibility of the numbers in the non-NP group was limited. I suggest
changing the color of the number or background.
In Fig.2, there are three groups; however, cutoff values were calculated only 10.5 mm and 8.0
mm. The authors should describe each cutoff value for three groups.
Linear scoring systems were described precisely; however, the authors should describe a
simplified method to evaluate the malignant potential for readers. I suggest to add the calculation
formula in the abstract or table.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Prediction of neoplastic gallbladder polyps in patients with different age level based on
preoperative ultrasound: a multi-center retrospective real-world study
Version: 0 Date: 28 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
The authors described a value of the linear scoring model to predict malignant GPs. The study
included many subjects, and statistical analysis was appropriate. I think it is a valuable report;
however, please revise several points.
In Figure 1A-C, the visibility of the numbers in the non-NP group was limited. I suggest
changing the color of the number or background.
In Fig.2, there are three groups; however, cutoff values were calculated only 10.5 mm and 8.0
mm. The authors should describe each cutoff value for three groups.
Linear scoring systems were described precisely; however, the authors should describe a
simplified method to evaluate the malignant potential for readers. I suggest to add the calculation
formula in the abstract or table.
assistant