Title: Clinical features and prognosis of acute-on-chronic liver failure in patients with
recompensated cirrhosis
Version: 1 Date: 14 Feb 2023
Reviewer:  David N Perdigoto
Reviewer's report:
Interesting manuscript concerning a relevant hot topic.
The data analysed is significant, but conclusions drawn should be interpreted cautiously because
of the particularities of the sample in study, namely almost half (49.2%) of the studied patients
have cirrhosis due to B hepatitis.
Studying the recompensated population is important. To understand better the recompensation
in the studied patients the authors should reveal the criteria used to define recompensation.
The manuscript requires revision of the language, some sentences need to be changed, for
instance: “Patients with recompensated cirrhosis had occured decompensation event(s), most
studies regarded them as decompensated cirrhosis patients.”
Title: Clinical features and prognosis of acute-on-chronic liver failure in patients with
recompensated cirrhosis
Version: 1 Date: 14 Feb 2023
Reviewer:  David N Perdigoto
Reviewer's report:
Interesting manuscript concerning a relevant hot topic.
The data analysed is significant, but conclusions drawn should be interpreted cautiously because
of the particularities of the sample in study, namely almost half (49.2%) of the studied patients
have cirrhosis due to B hepatitis.
Studying the recompensated population is important. To understand better the recompensation
in the studied patients the authors should reveal the criteria used to define recompensation.
The manuscript requires revision of the language, some sentences need to be changed, for
instance: “Patients with recompensated cirrhosis had occured decompensation event(s), most
studies regarded them as decompensated cirrhosis patients.”
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinical features and prognosis of acute-on-chronic liver failure in patients with
recompensated cirrhosis
Version: 1 Date: 14 Feb 2023
Reviewer:  David N Perdigoto
Reviewer's report:
Interesting manuscript concerning a relevant hot topic.
The data analysed is significant, but conclusions drawn should be interpreted cautiously because
of the particularities of the sample in study, namely almost half (49.2%) of the studied patients
have cirrhosis due to B hepatitis.
Studying the recompensated population is important. To understand better the recompensation
in the studied patients the authors should reveal the criteria used to define recompensation.
The manuscript requires revision of the language, some sentences need to be changed, for
instance: “Patients with recompensated cirrhosis had occured decompensation event(s), most
studies regarded them as decompensated cirrhosis patients.”
assistant