Title: Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of
24 patients
Version: 3 Date: 01 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
‘Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of 24
patients’
It is an interesting topic despite small sample size because of rarity.
The corrections which were wanted before, had been done.
There are a lot of grammatical errors which should be corrected such as:
In abstract T2WI------ T2-weighted imaging (T2WI)
Capital and small letters
CT image acquisition
The abdominal plain and contrast-enhanced CT scan--------- The pre-contrast and contrast-
enhanced CT scans
800-1,000 ml warm----800-1.000 ml warm
Fig. 3 Irregular mass in pancreatic tail. A patient with a occupying lesion---- a space occupying
lesion, etc …
Figures are demonstrative and informative.
In my opinion, it is more likely as a pictorial essay or case series. It is better to rewrite as a
pictorial essay or case series, or statistically compare with some other pancreatic cystic lesions'
imaging findings for research article.
Rejection, resubmit as a new article after rewriting with revisions
Title: Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of
24 patients
Version: 3 Date: 01 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
‘Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of 24
patients’
It is an interesting topic despite small sample size because of rarity.
The corrections which were wanted before, had been done.
There are a lot of grammatical errors which should be corrected such as:
In abstract T2WI------ T2-weighted imaging (T2WI)
Capital and small letters
CT image acquisition
The abdominal plain and contrast-enhanced CT scan--------- The pre-contrast and contrast-
enhanced CT scans
800-1,000 ml warm----800-1.000 ml warm
Fig. 3 Irregular mass in pancreatic tail. A patient with a occupying lesion---- a space occupying
lesion, etc …
Figures are demonstrative and informative.
In my opinion, it is more likely as a pictorial essay or case series. It is better to rewrite as a
pictorial essay or case series, or statistically compare with some other pancreatic cystic lesions'
imaging findings for research article.
Rejection, resubmit as a new article after rewriting with revisions
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of
24 patients
Version: 3 Date: 01 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
‘Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of 24
patients’
It is an interesting topic despite small sample size because of rarity.
The corrections which were wanted before, had been done.
There are a lot of grammatical errors which should be corrected such as:
In abstract T2WI------ T2-weighted imaging (T2WI)
Capital and small letters
CT image acquisition
The abdominal plain and contrast-enhanced CT scan--------- The pre-contrast and contrast-
enhanced CT scans
800-1,000 ml warm----800-1.000 ml warm
Fig. 3 Irregular mass in pancreatic tail. A patient with a occupying lesion---- a space occupying
lesion, etc …
Figures are demonstrative and informative.
In my opinion, it is more likely as a pictorial essay or case series. It is better to rewrite as a
pictorial essay or case series, or statistically compare with some other pancreatic cystic lesions'
imaging findings for research article.
Rejection, resubmit as a new article after rewriting with revisions
assistant