Title: Single center assessment of the role of Oakland score among patients admitted for acute
lower gastrointestinal bleeding
Version: 5 Date: 24 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors the article is very interesting to define the better criteria for a low gastrointestinal
bleeding patients’ safe discarge. In according to the letterature the bleedind causes are various
specially in the fraility patients. A severe Low Intestinal Bleeding with high Oakland score is
very difficult to manage.
Following my specific comments;
1) The structure of the paper is very clear.
2) The topic addressed is consistent with current literature.
3) In the body of the text, however, the complexity of the management is stressed.
4) The bibliography is in line with the topic of the article.
5) Although this article can provide useful guidance for clinical practice, some critical issues
should be addressed:
a) specify better the type of treatment
b) determine whether active bleeding was completely resolved at the time of discharge
d) stress better the role of the CCI
Title: Single center assessment of the role of Oakland score among patients admitted for acute
lower gastrointestinal bleeding
Version: 5 Date: 24 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors the article is very interesting to define the better criteria for a low gastrointestinal
bleeding patients’ safe discarge. In according to the letterature the bleedind causes are various
specially in the fraility patients. A severe Low Intestinal Bleeding with high Oakland score is
very difficult to manage.
Following my specific comments;
1) The structure of the paper is very clear.
2) The topic addressed is consistent with current literature.
3) In the body of the text, however, the complexity of the management is stressed.
4) The bibliography is in line with the topic of the article.
5) Although this article can provide useful guidance for clinical practice, some critical issues
should be addressed:
a) specify better the type of treatment
b) determine whether active bleeding was completely resolved at the time of discharge
d) stress better the role of the CCI
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Single center assessment of the role of Oakland score among patients admitted for acute
lower gastrointestinal bleeding
Version: 5 Date: 24 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors the article is very interesting to define the better criteria for a low gastrointestinal
bleeding patients’ safe discarge. In according to the letterature the bleedind causes are various
specially in the fraility patients. A severe Low Intestinal Bleeding with high Oakland score is
very difficult to manage.
Following my specific comments;
1) The structure of the paper is very clear.
2) The topic addressed is consistent with current literature.
3) In the body of the text, however, the complexity of the management is stressed.
4) The bibliography is in line with the topic of the article.
5) Although this article can provide useful guidance for clinical practice, some critical issues
should be addressed:
a) specify better the type of treatment
b) determine whether active bleeding was completely resolved at the time of discharge
d) stress better the role of the CCI
assistant