Title: Gastroparesis might not be Uncommon in Patients with Diabetes Mellitus in a Real-World
Clinical Setting: a cohort study
Version: 3 Date: 11 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
The authors have made point-by-point corrections to the peer review comments. But some issues
remain unresolved.
1. The authors conducted additional linear regression analyzes on the association between gastric
emptying time and diabetes mellitus with associated covariate (Table 3 and Table 4). They
should describe these analyzes in the Statistical analyses section.
2. Regarding Table 3, for delayed GET and nephropathy, the authors described as “# -2.922,
p=0.041”. But the description in the main text is “# -2.924, p=0.000”. Please correct either
description. Also, even though the CIs in the nephropathy are over 0 (-5.72,0.13 for delayed
GET, and -3.13,0.74 for Rapid GET), there are significant difference. Please check if the CIs
are correct.
3. Regarding Table 3, there is no description about hypoglycemia. The authors should add
descriptions of the results in the table.
Title: Gastroparesis might not be Uncommon in Patients with Diabetes Mellitus in a Real-World
Clinical Setting: a cohort study
Version: 3 Date: 11 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
The authors have made point-by-point corrections to the peer review comments. But some issues
remain unresolved.
1. The authors conducted additional linear regression analyzes on the association between gastric
emptying time and diabetes mellitus with associated covariate (Table 3 and Table 4). They
should describe these analyzes in the Statistical analyses section.
2. Regarding Table 3, for delayed GET and nephropathy, the authors described as “# -2.922,
p=0.041”. But the description in the main text is “# -2.924, p=0.000”. Please correct either
description. Also, even though the CIs in the nephropathy are over 0 (-5.72,0.13 for delayed
GET, and -3.13,0.74 for Rapid GET), there are significant difference. Please check if the CIs
are correct.
3. Regarding Table 3, there is no description about hypoglycemia. The authors should add
descriptions of the results in the table.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Gastroparesis might not be Uncommon in Patients with Diabetes Mellitus in a Real-World
Clinical Setting: a cohort study
Version: 3 Date: 11 Dec 2023
Reviewer's report:
The authors have made point-by-point corrections to the peer review comments. But some issues
remain unresolved.
1. The authors conducted additional linear regression analyzes on the association between gastric
emptying time and diabetes mellitus with associated covariate (Table 3 and Table 4). They
should describe these analyzes in the Statistical analyses section.
2. Regarding Table 3, for delayed GET and nephropathy, the authors described as “# -2.922,
p=0.041”. But the description in the main text is “# -2.924, p=0.000”. Please correct either
description. Also, even though the CIs in the nephropathy are over 0 (-5.72,0.13 for delayed
GET, and -3.13,0.74 for Rapid GET), there are significant difference. Please check if the CIs
are correct.
3. Regarding Table 3, there is no description about hypoglycemia. The authors should add
descriptions of the results in the table.
assistant