Title: Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of
24 patients
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I think this is a very informative article that summarizes the imaging and pathology of pancreatic
epidermoid cysts and is well organized.
Major: To make this article even more educational, how about the following? In other words,
I would like to know what the 24 cases looked like on CT/MRI that led to that preoperative
diagnosis, so it would be good to have a table (as in supple 1) summarizing the imaging
characteristics of the 24 cases. Please summarize the imaging findings together with the
preoperative diagnosis as SUPPLEMENT 2.
Minor:
(bottom of page 4, in Image acquisition)
Is taking 800-1000 ml of warm water a commonly done imaging method? Please cite any articles.
Title: Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of
24 patients
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I think this is a very informative article that summarizes the imaging and pathology of pancreatic
epidermoid cysts and is well organized.
Major: To make this article even more educational, how about the following? In other words,
I would like to know what the 24 cases looked like on CT/MRI that led to that preoperative
diagnosis, so it would be good to have a table (as in supple 1) summarizing the imaging
characteristics of the 24 cases. Please summarize the imaging findings together with the
preoperative diagnosis as SUPPLEMENT 2.
Minor:
(bottom of page 4, in Image acquisition)
Is taking 800-1000 ml of warm water a commonly done imaging method? Please cite any articles.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Imaging features of epidermoid cysts in intrapancreatic spleen: A single center study of
24 patients
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I think this is a very informative article that summarizes the imaging and pathology of pancreatic
epidermoid cysts and is well organized.
Major: To make this article even more educational, how about the following? In other words,
I would like to know what the 24 cases looked like on CT/MRI that led to that preoperative
diagnosis, so it would be good to have a table (as in supple 1) summarizing the imaging
characteristics of the 24 cases. Please summarize the imaging findings together with the
preoperative diagnosis as SUPPLEMENT 2.
Minor:
(bottom of page 4, in Image acquisition)
Is taking 800-1000 ml of warm water a commonly done imaging method? Please cite any articles.
assistant