Title: Meta-analysis of the efficacy of applying reduced surgery for the treatment of
asymptomatic unresectable advanced gastric cancer
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This meta-analysis initially confirmed the efficacy and safety of reduction surgery for advanced
gastric cancer patients without obvious symptoms was not significantly superior to conservative
therapy. Although studies included were small samples, this topic is novel and insightful to some
extent. I have the following comments:
Firstly, in the Introduction Section, Could you cite our team 's two latest articles named"Defining
nomograms for predicting prognosis of early and late recurrence in gastric cancer patients
after radical gastrectomy"and "Development and validation of nomograms for predicting the
prognosis of early and late recurrence of advanced gastric cancer after radical surgery based
on post-recurrence survival" in appropriate location? I think it's important to improve your
manuscript's quality.
Secondly, Please make some necessary complements about the possible  reasons and
explanations of this result in Discussion Section.
Last but not least, please check the spelling and Grammer again in your manuscript carefully.
Title: Meta-analysis of the efficacy of applying reduced surgery for the treatment of
asymptomatic unresectable advanced gastric cancer
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This meta-analysis initially confirmed the efficacy and safety of reduction surgery for advanced
gastric cancer patients without obvious symptoms was not significantly superior to conservative
therapy. Although studies included were small samples, this topic is novel and insightful to some
extent. I have the following comments:
Firstly, in the Introduction Section, Could you cite our team 's two latest articles named"Defining
nomograms for predicting prognosis of early and late recurrence in gastric cancer patients
after radical gastrectomy"and "Development and validation of nomograms for predicting the
prognosis of early and late recurrence of advanced gastric cancer after radical surgery based
on post-recurrence survival" in appropriate location? I think it's important to improve your
manuscript's quality.
Secondly, Please make some necessary complements about the possible  reasons and
explanations of this result in Discussion Section.
Last but not least, please check the spelling and Grammer again in your manuscript carefully.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Meta-analysis of the efficacy of applying reduced surgery for the treatment of
asymptomatic unresectable advanced gastric cancer
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This meta-analysis initially confirmed the efficacy and safety of reduction surgery for advanced
gastric cancer patients without obvious symptoms was not significantly superior to conservative
therapy. Although studies included were small samples, this topic is novel and insightful to some
extent. I have the following comments:
Firstly, in the Introduction Section, Could you cite our team 's two latest articles named"Defining
nomograms for predicting prognosis of early and late recurrence in gastric cancer patients
after radical gastrectomy"and "Development and validation of nomograms for predicting the
prognosis of early and late recurrence of advanced gastric cancer after radical surgery based
on post-recurrence survival" in appropriate location? I think it's important to improve your
manuscript's quality.
Secondly, Please make some necessary complements about the possible  reasons and
explanations of this result in Discussion Section.
Last but not least, please check the spelling and Grammer again in your manuscript carefully.
assistant