Title: The physiological and psychological effects of cognitive behavior therapy on patients
with inflammatory bowel disease before COVID-19: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 19 Aug 2021
Reviewer's report:
The review is comprehensive, but requires certain modifications.
1. Section 2.1.2- Inclusion criteria- The diagnostic criteria for IBD need modifications.
2. What was the IBD treatment in the group which received CBT, and were the cases and controls
similar in terms of standard IBD therapy?
3. Why were two studies with same patients included separately, authors should provide
justification in the methods section
4. Heterogeneity in terms of different interventions and different outcomes is another limitation
which the authors should mention
5. In the discussion authors have referred to a systematic review in the discussion, (page 8,
second last paragraph). Does this review refers to patients with IBS or to IBD ? Authors provide
a citation for this study also
Title: The physiological and psychological effects of cognitive behavior therapy on patients
with inflammatory bowel disease before COVID-19: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 19 Aug 2021
Reviewer's report:
The review is comprehensive, but requires certain modifications.
1. Section 2.1.2- Inclusion criteria- The diagnostic criteria for IBD need modifications.
2. What was the IBD treatment in the group which received CBT, and were the cases and controls
similar in terms of standard IBD therapy?
3. Why were two studies with same patients included separately, authors should provide
justification in the methods section
4. Heterogeneity in terms of different interventions and different outcomes is another limitation
which the authors should mention
5. In the discussion authors have referred to a systematic review in the discussion, (page 8,
second last paragraph). Does this review refers to patients with IBS or to IBD ? Authors provide
a citation for this study also
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The physiological and psychological effects of cognitive behavior therapy on patients
with inflammatory bowel disease before COVID-19: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 19 Aug 2021
Reviewer's report:
The review is comprehensive, but requires certain modifications.
1. Section 2.1.2- Inclusion criteria- The diagnostic criteria for IBD need modifications.
2. What was the IBD treatment in the group which received CBT, and were the cases and controls
similar in terms of standard IBD therapy?
3. Why were two studies with same patients included separately, authors should provide
justification in the methods section
4. Heterogeneity in terms of different interventions and different outcomes is another limitation
which the authors should mention
5. In the discussion authors have referred to a systematic review in the discussion, (page 8,
second last paragraph). Does this review refers to patients with IBS or to IBD ? Authors provide
a citation for this study also
assistant