Title: Clinicopathologic and endoscopic characteristics of ten patients with gastric
hamartomatous inverted polyp: a single center case series
Version: 1 Date: 30 Jan 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review your valuable paper.
It was very interesting manuscript that the clinicopathological summary of 10 cases at your
institution and the previously reported 45 cases of gastric hamartomatous inverted polyp.
Please allow me to confirm the following points about this paper.
# Is the evaluation of H. pylori infection status performed only by urea breath test?
# I think it would be better to include the company of the urea breath test and the definition of
a positive result in the Material and methods section.
# I think it is necessary to mention the history of proton pump inhibitors in the patient background
because it affects the urea breath test.
# How was atrophic gastritis determined?
# Is the pathological evaluation only HE staining? Is immunostaining performed? This point
should be clearly stated.
# Please correction of the sentence on page 6
~ except for one patient(1, 1.8%) who had 2 GHIPs.
# ~except for one patient(1/55, 1.8%) who had 2 GHIPs.
Title: Clinicopathologic and endoscopic characteristics of ten patients with gastric
hamartomatous inverted polyp: a single center case series
Version: 1 Date: 30 Jan 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review your valuable paper.
It was very interesting manuscript that the clinicopathological summary of 10 cases at your
institution and the previously reported 45 cases of gastric hamartomatous inverted polyp.
Please allow me to confirm the following points about this paper.
# Is the evaluation of H. pylori infection status performed only by urea breath test?
# I think it would be better to include the company of the urea breath test and the definition of
a positive result in the Material and methods section.
# I think it is necessary to mention the history of proton pump inhibitors in the patient background
because it affects the urea breath test.
# How was atrophic gastritis determined?
# Is the pathological evaluation only HE staining? Is immunostaining performed? This point
should be clearly stated.
# Please correction of the sentence on page 6
~ except for one patient(1, 1.8%) who had 2 GHIPs.
# ~except for one patient(1/55, 1.8%) who had 2 GHIPs.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Clinicopathologic and endoscopic characteristics of ten patients with gastric
hamartomatous inverted polyp: a single center case series
Version: 1 Date: 30 Jan 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review your valuable paper.
It was very interesting manuscript that the clinicopathological summary of 10 cases at your
institution and the previously reported 45 cases of gastric hamartomatous inverted polyp.
Please allow me to confirm the following points about this paper.
# Is the evaluation of H. pylori infection status performed only by urea breath test?
# I think it would be better to include the company of the urea breath test and the definition of
a positive result in the Material and methods section.
# I think it is necessary to mention the history of proton pump inhibitors in the patient background
because it affects the urea breath test.
# How was atrophic gastritis determined?
# Is the pathological evaluation only HE staining? Is immunostaining performed? This point
should be clearly stated.
# Please correction of the sentence on page 6
~ except for one patient(1, 1.8%) who had 2 GHIPs.
# ~except for one patient(1/55, 1.8%) who had 2 GHIPs.
assistant