Title: Title: Association of sarcopenia with serum ferritin levels and hepatic indices like NFS
and FIB-4 in NAFLD patients
Version: 2 Date: 08 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The paper: Association of sarcopenia with serum ferritin levels and hepatic indices like NFS and
FIB-4 in NAFLD patients presents some knowledge on selected parameters of liver function
and relation to sarcopenia.
Major flaws are:
1. Methods are not described properly. The liver steatosis in ultrasound- how was it described?
The most important: how was sarcopenia evaluated with ultrasound- no data on it. Statistical
methods- not described properly. Why were the markers of liver fibrosis (FIB-4) chosen for
evaluations?? The ferritin level is  often elevated in liver injury – why was it chosen??
2. Results- the are no basic results- what was the results of sarcopenia measurements, other lab
tests ??
The English needs corrections,
I can not recommend the paper for publication
Title: Title: Association of sarcopenia with serum ferritin levels and hepatic indices like NFS
and FIB-4 in NAFLD patients
Version: 2 Date: 08 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The paper: Association of sarcopenia with serum ferritin levels and hepatic indices like NFS and
FIB-4 in NAFLD patients presents some knowledge on selected parameters of liver function
and relation to sarcopenia.
Major flaws are:
1. Methods are not described properly. The liver steatosis in ultrasound- how was it described?
The most important: how was sarcopenia evaluated with ultrasound- no data on it. Statistical
methods- not described properly. Why were the markers of liver fibrosis (FIB-4) chosen for
evaluations?? The ferritin level is  often elevated in liver injury – why was it chosen??
2. Results- the are no basic results- what was the results of sarcopenia measurements, other lab
tests ??
The English needs corrections,
I can not recommend the paper for publication
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Title: Association of sarcopenia with serum ferritin levels and hepatic indices like NFS
and FIB-4 in NAFLD patients
Version: 2 Date: 08 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The paper: Association of sarcopenia with serum ferritin levels and hepatic indices like NFS and
FIB-4 in NAFLD patients presents some knowledge on selected parameters of liver function
and relation to sarcopenia.
Major flaws are:
1. Methods are not described properly. The liver steatosis in ultrasound- how was it described?
The most important: how was sarcopenia evaluated with ultrasound- no data on it. Statistical
methods- not described properly. Why were the markers of liver fibrosis (FIB-4) chosen for
evaluations?? The ferritin level is  often elevated in liver injury – why was it chosen??
2. Results- the are no basic results- what was the results of sarcopenia measurements, other lab
tests ??
The English needs corrections,
I can not recommend the paper for publication
assistant