Title: Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection has high complete resection rate in rectal
carcinoid tumor
Version: 2 Date: 19 Sep 2021
Reviewer's report:
Ms. Ref. No. ID 4447f43e-f5a9-4a2b-bb48-9b3bd7546c39
Title: Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection has high complete resection rate in rectal
carcinoid tumor
Journal: BMC Gastroenterology
Dear Dr. Su:
We find your interesting paper. Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection is a good and
easy technique for complete resection for rectal carcinoid. There are some problems about your
paper.
1. The surgery for malignant tumor is usually safety margin of resection. Can you explain 2
cases of inadequate resection in surgery group?
2. Do you suggest the interval time of follow-up in incomplete resection cases, especial just
biopsy case?
3. How do you manage your recurrent cases?
4. There are few alphabet error including outcmes (outcomes?) in the method of abstract and
LEMR9(28 patients) and EMRC 9(25patients) in the results.
Title: Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection has high complete resection rate in rectal
carcinoid tumor
Version: 2 Date: 19 Sep 2021
Reviewer's report:
Ms. Ref. No. ID 4447f43e-f5a9-4a2b-bb48-9b3bd7546c39
Title: Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection has high complete resection rate in rectal
carcinoid tumor
Journal: BMC Gastroenterology
Dear Dr. Su:
We find your interesting paper. Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection is a good and
easy technique for complete resection for rectal carcinoid. There are some problems about your
paper.
1. The surgery for malignant tumor is usually safety margin of resection. Can you explain 2
cases of inadequate resection in surgery group?
2. Do you suggest the interval time of follow-up in incomplete resection cases, especial just
biopsy case?
3. How do you manage your recurrent cases?
4. There are few alphabet error including outcmes (outcomes?) in the method of abstract and
LEMR9(28 patients) and EMRC 9(25patients) in the results.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection has high complete resection rate in rectal
carcinoid tumor
Version: 2 Date: 19 Sep 2021
Reviewer's report:
Ms. Ref. No. ID 4447f43e-f5a9-4a2b-bb48-9b3bd7546c39
Title: Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection has high complete resection rate in rectal
carcinoid tumor
Journal: BMC Gastroenterology
Dear Dr. Su:
We find your interesting paper. Ligation-assisted endoscopic mucosal resection is a good and
easy technique for complete resection for rectal carcinoid. There are some problems about your
paper.
1. The surgery for malignant tumor is usually safety margin of resection. Can you explain 2
cases of inadequate resection in surgery group?
2. Do you suggest the interval time of follow-up in incomplete resection cases, especial just
biopsy case?
3. How do you manage your recurrent cases?
4. There are few alphabet error including outcmes (outcomes?) in the method of abstract and
LEMR9(28 patients) and EMRC 9(25patients) in the results.
assistant