Title: Value of CT sinography and analysis of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis for abdominal
wall sinus
Version: 1 Date: 03 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this important manuscript. Here are my comments and
suggestions.
This is a good idea for the study but concepts should be different. First, We should ask ourselves
why do we need this imaging method. Will it change our management plan? I would divide the
groups of patients. Why do we need sinography after inguinal hernia repair.? It is difficult to
believe that the sinus tract communicates with the bowel lumen. What will be changed in the
treatment plan?
Enterocutaneous fistulas are another story.
Page 2, line 17-18. What about umbilical pilonidal sinus and persistent urachus.
Title: Value of CT sinography and analysis of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis for abdominal
wall sinus
Version: 1 Date: 03 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this important manuscript. Here are my comments and
suggestions.
This is a good idea for the study but concepts should be different. First, We should ask ourselves
why do we need this imaging method. Will it change our management plan? I would divide the
groups of patients. Why do we need sinography after inguinal hernia repair.? It is difficult to
believe that the sinus tract communicates with the bowel lumen. What will be changed in the
treatment plan?
Enterocutaneous fistulas are another story.
Page 2, line 17-18. What about umbilical pilonidal sinus and persistent urachus.
Please review this paper.
user
Title: Value of CT sinography and analysis of missed diagnosis and misdiagnosis for abdominal
wall sinus
Version: 1 Date: 03 Mar 2022
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this important manuscript. Here are my comments and
suggestions.
This is a good idea for the study but concepts should be different. First, We should ask ourselves
why do we need this imaging method. Will it change our management plan? I would divide the
groups of patients. Why do we need sinography after inguinal hernia repair.? It is difficult to
believe that the sinus tract communicates with the bowel lumen. What will be changed in the
treatment plan?
Enterocutaneous fistulas are another story.
Page 2, line 17-18. What about umbilical pilonidal sinus and persistent urachus.
assistant