Reviewer's report
Title:Is preoperative MRCP necessary for patients with gallstones? An analysis
of the factors related to missed diagnosis of choledocholithiasis by preoperative
ultrasound
Version:2Date:7 October 2014
Reviewer: Andrea Cariati
Reviewer's report:
The discussione and the conclusion chapter must be changed according to this
three articles that must be cited in the test and in the references; in fact at the
moment "Preoperative MRCP cannot be reccomended routinely due to costs".:
papers that report this are:
1) Nebiker CA et al: Is routine MRCP justified prio to cholecystectomy ?
lagenbecks Arch Surg 2009; 394: 1005-10
2) Shapey IM. Biliary tract imaging. Durg laparoscop Endos Perct Tech 2012:
22: 459-62
3) Epelboym L, Winner M al. MRCP is not a .. J Gastrointest Surg 2013 17 863-
71
Reviewer's report
Title:Is preoperative MRCP necessary for patients with gallstones? An analysis
of the factors related to missed diagnosis of choledocholithiasis by preoperative
ultrasound
Version:2Date:7 October 2014
Reviewer: Andrea Cariati
Reviewer's report:
The discussione and the conclusion chapter must be changed according to this
three articles that must be cited in the test and in the references; in fact at the
moment "Preoperative MRCP cannot be reccomended routinely due to costs".:
papers that report this are:
1) Nebiker CA et al: Is routine MRCP justified prio to cholecystectomy ?
lagenbecks Arch Surg 2009; 394: 1005-10
2) Shapey IM. Biliary tract imaging. Durg laparoscop Endos Perct Tech 2012:
22: 459-62
3) Epelboym L, Winner M al. MRCP is not a .. J Gastrointest Surg 2013 17 863-
71
Please review this paper.
user
Reviewer's report
Title:Is preoperative MRCP necessary for patients with gallstones? An analysis
of the factors related to missed diagnosis of choledocholithiasis by preoperative
ultrasound
Version:2Date:7 October 2014
Reviewer: Andrea Cariati
Reviewer's report:
The discussione and the conclusion chapter must be changed according to this
three articles that must be cited in the test and in the references; in fact at the
moment "Preoperative MRCP cannot be reccomended routinely due to costs".:
papers that report this are:
1) Nebiker CA et al: Is routine MRCP justified prio to cholecystectomy ?
lagenbecks Arch Surg 2009; 394: 1005-10
2) Shapey IM. Biliary tract imaging. Durg laparoscop Endos Perct Tech 2012:
22: 459-62
3) Epelboym L, Winner M al. MRCP is not a .. J Gastrointest Surg 2013 17 863-
71
assistant