Title: The longterm impact of post-cholecystectomy major bile duct injury on liver stiffness.
Version: 4 Date: 13 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Tri Hening Rahayatri
Reviewer's report:
1. Based on research methods, this research was conducted on patients who underwent open and
conventional procedures. However, the research background only mention laparoscopy. Please
correct the introduction.
2. The manuscript improvements are good. However, to produce a better manuscript, grammar
should be improved further.
3. This sentence on page 6 should be revised: Overall, there were 5 patients who developed
26.3% (n=5) anastomotic site strictures including two newly developed strictures following
repair in the center.
4. The first sentence on discussion should be clarified: In this cohort of 50 patients with BDI,
20 had Strasberg E injuries. Of these patients 21.1% had F3/4 fibrosis.
There were only 19 patients with BDI included in the study
Title: The longterm impact of post-cholecystectomy major bile duct injury on liver stiffness.
Version: 4 Date: 13 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Tri Hening Rahayatri
Reviewer's report:
1. Based on research methods, this research was conducted on patients who underwent open and
conventional procedures. However, the research background only mention laparoscopy. Please
correct the introduction.
2. The manuscript improvements are good. However, to produce a better manuscript, grammar
should be improved further.
3. This sentence on page 6 should be revised: Overall, there were 5 patients who developed
26.3% (n=5) anastomotic site strictures including two newly developed strictures following
repair in the center.
4. The first sentence on discussion should be clarified: In this cohort of 50 patients with BDI,
20 had Strasberg E injuries. Of these patients 21.1% had F3/4 fibrosis.
There were only 19 patients with BDI included in the study
Please review this paper.
user
Title: The longterm impact of post-cholecystectomy major bile duct injury on liver stiffness.
Version: 4 Date: 13 Aug 2024
Reviewer:  Tri Hening Rahayatri
Reviewer's report:
1. Based on research methods, this research was conducted on patients who underwent open and
conventional procedures. However, the research background only mention laparoscopy. Please
correct the introduction.
2. The manuscript improvements are good. However, to produce a better manuscript, grammar
should be improved further.
3. This sentence on page 6 should be revised: Overall, there were 5 patients who developed
26.3% (n=5) anastomotic site strictures including two newly developed strictures following
repair in the center.
4. The first sentence on discussion should be clarified: In this cohort of 50 patients with BDI,
20 had Strasberg E injuries. Of these patients 21.1% had F3/4 fibrosis.
There were only 19 patients with BDI included in the study
assistant