--- license: mit language: - en tags: - analysis-results - representational-similarity-analysis - rsa - fmri - expert-neurons - gpt-2 - mitchell-2008 - interpretability - brain-alignment - chain-of-thought --- # experts-ml-selfcond-result This dataset contains the **complete results archive** for the `experts-ml-selfcond` research project — a fork of Apple's [selfcond](https://github.com/xavisuau/selfcond) (ICML 2022) extended with fMRI brain alignment experiments via Representational Similarity Analysis (RSA). > ⚠️ **This is a companion results artifact**, not a training dataset. It contains analysis outputs (RDMs, RSA statistics, expert neuron tables, visualizations) generated from the pipeline. See [`jucamohedano/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507_custom_60_cot`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/jucamohedano/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507_custom_60_cot) for the input Chain-of-Thought sentences. ## What's Inside The archive (`results_complete.tar.xz`) contains the full `results/` directory (8.6 GB uncompressed, 1.6 GB compressed) with **55,282 files** spanning all pipeline stages: ### Directory Structure ``` results/ ├── brain_rdm/ # Brain RDMs per subject × grid region │ └── .../default/ # Original (non-normalized) brain RDMs │ └── .../voxel_normalized/ # Per-voxel z-scored (normalization robustness check) │ └── .../voxel_normalized_original_grid/ # Normalized, original grid shape ├── compute_responses/ # Cached model activations (GPT-2, 12 layers) ├── compute_expertise/ # AP scores per neuron per concept (expertise.csv, .json) ├── unique_experts/ # Filtered unique expert neuron sets (correlation thresholded) ├── expert_overlap/ # Jaccard similarity between concept expert sets ├── word_features/ # Per-layer feature matrices [60 words × |E_l| neurons] ├── subspace_gaze/ # PCA/LAT concept subspaces & UMAP visualizations ├── steering/ # Steering vector outputs & generation samples ├── steering_validation/ # Causal validation of expert vectors ├── rsa/ # RSA comparison results │ ├── .../default/ # Original RSA: expert vs. dense embeddings │ └── .../voxel_normalized_*/ # Voxel-normalized reproducibility runs ├── *.png # Aggregate visualizations (heatmaps, scatter plots, etc.) └── *.json # Hydra configs, metadata, run logs ``` ### Key Result Types | File | Description | |------|-------------| | `brain_rdms.pkl` | Per-subject brain RDMs (60×60, 1−Pearson r) | | `expertise.csv` | AP scores, forcing values per neuron per layer | | `rsa_results.csv` | RSA statistics: Spearman rho, Cohen's d, p-values, FDR correction | | `*_rdm.npy` | Model RDMs (60×60) per layer, per condition (expert / dense) | | `*_features.npy` | Word feature matrices [60 words × N experts] | | `*.png` | Heatmaps, effect size plots, scatter comparisons | ## Key Scientific Results ### Original Analysis (non-normalized brain RDMs) - **MLP projection layer** (`mlp.c_proj`) at AP ≥ 0.6: expert neurons significantly outperform dense embeddings (mean Cohen's d = **+0.627**) - Attention layers require stricter filtering; MLP layers align better than attention ### Voxel Normalization Robustness Check Per-voxel z-scoring was applied as a methodological control (see `scripts/compute_brain_rdm.py`): | Layer | Original Mean d | Voxel-Normalized Mean d | |-------|:-:|:-:| | `mlp.c_proj` (AP=0.6) | +0.627 | **−0.523** | | `attn.c_proj` (AP=0.7) | +0.536 | **−0.551** | | `mlp.c_fc` (AP=0.6) | +0.443 | **−0.010** | | `attn.c_attn` (AP=0.7) | +0.412 | **−0.522** | **Finding:** Per-voxel normalization reverses or eliminates the expert neuron advantage across all layer components, suggesting high-variance voxels were driving the original brain alignment signal. See `my_docs/voxel_normalization_analysis.md` for the full analysis. ## How to Use ```bash pip install huggingface_hub # Download the tarball (requires access to this private dataset) from huggingface_hub import hf_hub_download hf_hub_download( repo_id="jucamohedano/experts-ml-selfcond-result", filename="results_complete.tar.xz", ) # Extract tar -xJf results_complete.tar.xz ``` Alternatively, browse individual files on the [Hugging Face dataset page](https://huggingface.co/datasets/jucamohedano/experts-ml-selfcond-result). ## Reproducing the Analysis The pipeline is orchestrated via Hydra in `run_pipeline.py`: ```bash python run_pipeline.py task=brain_rdm # Compute brain RDMs python run_pipeline.py task=compute_responses # Cache model activations python run_pipeline.py task=compute_expertise # Compute AP scores python run_pipeline.py task=word_feature_extraction # Extract expert/dense features python run_pipeline.py task=rsa # RSA comparison ``` ## Citation If you use the original self-conditioning methods, cite: > Xavier Suau, Luca Zappella, Nicholas Apostoloff. *Self-Conditioning Pre-Trained Language Models*. ICML 2022. If you use the brain-alignment/RSA extensions, refer to this repository and the final report: [JuanCamachoMohedano-257536-Project-Experts.pdf](https://github.com/jucamohedano/experts-ml-selfcond). ## Related Datasets - **Input sentences**: [`jucamohedano/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507_custom_60_cot`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/jucamohedano/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Instruct-2507_custom_60_cot) - **Project code**: [`jucamohedano/experts-ml-selfcond`](https://github.com/jucamohedano/experts-ml-selfcond)