---
license: cc-by-4.0
---

Annotation data columns

`ea_justification_annotations.csv` contains 1,176 rows and 83 columns.

| Column group | Count | Labels/range | Description |
|---|---:|---|---|
| `dataset`, `item_id`, `sample_rank`, `annotation_batch` | 4 | `dataset`: `hansard` or `qam`; rank: positive integer | Dataset source, item identifier, sampling order, and annotation batch. |
| `topic`, `argument`, `original_argument`, `argument_group` | 4 | `argument_group`: `real` or `synthetic` | Topic and argument text, original argument, and generation status. |
| `emotional_appeal_injector_model`, `source_emotional_appeal_type`, `source_emotional_appeal_strength` | 3 | Model/human provenance; seven EA types; strength `2–5` | Argument-generation provenance and intended appeal label. |
| `context`, `original_context`, `context_group` | 3 | `context_group`: `real` or `synthetic` | Presented context, original context, and perturbation status. |
| `context_perturber_model`, `context_aspect`, `context_level` | 3 | Aspect: `mag`, `prob`, `ris`, `sprox`, `tprox`; level: `LOW`, `MEDIUM`, `HIGH` | Perturbation model, aspect, and target level. |
| `context_pair_id`, `context_pair_role` | 2 | Role: `original` or `perturbed` | Original/perturbed context pairing. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_id` | 5 | Anonymized categorical IDs | Annotator identifiers. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_context_support` | 5 | Integer `−3–3` | Argument-context support rating. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_emotional_appeal_type` | 5 | Nine EA-type labels | Primary emotional appeal. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_emotional_appeal_strength` | 5 | Integer `1–5` | Emotional-appeal strength. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_emotion_type_fit` | 5 | Integer `1–5` or `not_applicable` | Fit between the argument and identified emotion type. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_evidential_proportionality` | 5 | Integer `1–5` or `not_applicable` | Proportionality of the appeal to its evidence/context. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_evidential_proportionality_reasons` | 5 | Pipe-separated selection from nine reason labels | Reasons for the evidential-proportionality rating. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_normative_acceptability` | 5 | Integer `1–5` or `not_applicable` | Normative acceptability rating. |
| `annotator_{1..5}_overall_justification` | 5 | Integer `1–5` or `not_applicable` | Overall justification rating. |
| `paper_top3_annotator_{1..3}_id` | 3 | Anonymized categorical IDs | Annotators selected per batch for the paper analysis. |
| `{dimension}_all5_majority` | 8 | Same domain as the corresponding dimension | Majority aggregates over all available annotators. |
| `{dimension}_paper_top3_majority` | 8 | Same domain as the corresponding dimension | Majority aggregates over the selected top three.